Allegheny County Councilman Sam DeMarco, head of the county’s Republican Party, has called on his Democratic colleague Bethany Hallam to resign because of social media posts she published over the weekend concerning the attempted assassination of former President Donald Trump in Butler County.

Mr. DeMarco said in an interview that his position on Ms. Hallam’s actions has been consistent since the two have served together on council. He said that Ms. Hallam has been getting more strident in her rhetoric over political issues, culminating with two recent tweets.

One of them, posted just as news of the assassination attempt was breaking, consisted of Ms. Hallam quote-tweeting a popular conservative account on X showing a video of the Trump rally and claiming “Trump got shot in the side of the head at his rally in Pennsylvania” with Ms. Hallam’s comment: “Wow, the crime in Butler County is out of control!” — a post she has since deleted. When criticized on X for the deleted post, she responded “I realized I didn’t know [expletive] about what happened and shouldn’t say anything unless I do so I deleted it.”

A day earlier, she had posted a meme with a quote from Thomas Jefferson which states: “The tree of of Liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants.” That post remains.

Advertise with us

Ms. Hallam declined to comment on Mr. DeMarco’s calls on her to resign.

Mr. DeMarco said that the tweet Saturday was what triggered him to call for her resignation. He is also talking with other council members to gauge other possible actions, including a censure vote, calling on members to stop attending council meetings in order to stall formal business, or other options.

Read More

The two have been at odds throughout their tenures on council. Mr. DeMarco first introduced a call to censure Ms. Hallam in January 2023, after Ms. Hallam called Elliot Howsie, a county judge and former chair of the county’s Jail Oversight Board, a “prick” during one of those meetings. The censure motion failed 6-9.

County Council President Pat Catena said Tuesday that he hadn’t talked to Mr. DeMarco about his calls for Ms. Hallam to resign — or any other proposals — and declined further comment.

Mr. DeMarco echoed Gov. Josh Shapiro, President Joe Biden, former president Donald Trump and House speaker Mike Johnson’s calls to tone down the political rhetoric.

Advertise with us

“Debate needs to be based upon ideas, and shouldn’t be about personalities,” Mr. DeMarco said. “We shouldn’t be about personal attacks.”

It’s unclear whether any of Mr. DeMarco’s proposals would gain traction in council, which has a range of ideological views. But he said Monday that if Democratic Councilman Bob Macey can lose his seat on the board of the Southwestern Pennsylvania Commission over comments he made on immigration during a public hearing regarding a cease-fire resolution regarding the Israel-Hamas war, then action against Ms. Hallam should be considered by his colleagues.

Mr. Macey said he supports Mr. DeMarco’s efforts.

“I think people’s actions speak louder than words,” Mr. Macey told the Post-Gazette. “I believe that [Ms. Hallam] should be called on her actions, and if the other council persons [and] her supporters don’t go along with a sanction, or some type of motion, then that’s on their shoulders.”

The council is currently on its summer break and isn’t scheduled to reconvene until Aug. 20.