It took the city of Erie just six months to implement a rental registry program that now has lasted for 14 years. For 16 years, Pittsburgh officials have labored over multiple iterations of a rental registration ordinance to no avail.
Rental registries, sometimes referred to as rental permitting, is a tactic successfully used by Pennsylvania cities and municipalities to hold landlords accountable and ensure the safety of renters. At its simplest level, rental registries require landlords to receive a city permit contingent upon passing a routine building inspection.
Pittsburgh, in an effort to crack down on bad landlords and ensure tenant safety, has been trying for years to enact some type of rental registry program, but has been met with lawsuits claiming governmental overreach and excessive fees.
Without a registry, Pittsburgh City Council members have previously argued, there is no way to know exactly how many rental units are in the city and whether they’re inhabitable.
Public safety is at the top of the list of reasons why Pittsburgh should have a rental registry, council President Daniel Lavelle said.
“It’s critical for any city in America to be able to inspect all of its [buildings], whether large commercial or in this case, rentals,” he said.
Read More
Many cities with such programs say they’ve seen a turnaround in the number of dilapidated buildings and absentee landlords.
The year before Erie’s implementation in 2010, there were nine deaths in rental properties, according to Andy Zimmerman, the city’s code enforcement bureau manager.
“That was just unacceptable and basically how we got the program off the ground and running,” he said.
Bruce Henry, Harrisburg’s deputy codes administrator, said that city’s ordinance has been beneficial. Harrisburg’s ordinance, created in 2011, requires landlords to maintain a license and register properties annually. A property also must be inspected once every five years, unless a tenant makes a complaint, when another inspection will be scheduled.
“We have a lot of rental properties, and I think we’ve done a lot better in keeping on top of them and keeping them maintained,” he said.
In both Erie and Harrisburg, the ordinances passed through city council and were quickly signed by the mayors without issue.
Officials in Allentown, Lehigh County, said a program in effect there since 1995 has been beneficial.
“This work has helped to decrease unsafe and unhealthy living conditions of tenant-occupied properties,” said Heidi Westerman, Allentown’s director of the bureau of building standards.
It’s not just large cities that have rental registries. Smaller municipalities in Allegheny County, including Sharpsburg, Millvale and McKees Rocks, all have permitting processes and inspection requirements for rental units.
Pittsburgh’s Long Battle
Former Mayor Luke Ravenstahl signed the first rental registration ordinance in Pittsburgh in 2008. It required a $12 fee. The next year, the Apartment Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh filed a lawsuit, and while the city and multiple landlord groups tried to negotiate terms of the ordinance, nothing was ever agreed upon, effectively killing the legislation.
For the next five years, Pittsburgh City Council toiled over the details of a new ordinance.
In 2014, newly elected Mayor Bill Peduto and council introduced a second version of the ordinance. Landlords weren’t happy with this one, either.
It required a yearly fee between $45 and $65 per unit, less if the building had more than 10 units, and contact information for the property owner and anyone else responsible for the building’s upkeep.
Mr. Peduto estimated that the fee could add $1.6 million to the city’s bank account.
But state law says fees may only be associated with the cost of administering the service. That meant the city couldn’t make money off the fee, which otherwise would be considered a tax. A judge later ruled that the $65 fee was too high.
In 2021, council passed another version, with landlords having to pay $14 per unit for inspection, $16 for application intake and $5.50 for travel expenses.
Commonwealth Court Senior Judge Mary Hanna Leavitt struck down that legislation, saying it placed an excessive burden on landlords.
The city appealed to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, which dismissed the appeal because during the appeal process, council had passed yet another iteration of the ordinance, this time adding in provisions for short-term rentals such as Airbnbs.
Council passed that legislation last September, though it has yet to be enforced and has also been met with lawsuits. Pittsburgh’s Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspections is not currently taking permit applications for rental units.
“Pittsburgh can’t get it right because they’re so wrong,” said Lawrence Fisher, a lawyer who has represented landlord groups.
City officials increased their calls for a rental registry after the Easter Sunday shooting at an Airbnb unit on the North Side that left two teenagers dead and many others injured.
The most recent version of the ordinance also included provisions for building owners who operate short-term rental properties. That legislation started as a way to regulate short-term rentals and was based on the 2021 version of the rental registry.
After Judge Leavitt struck down that legislation, council members went back to the drawing board. The legislation currently on the books requires owners of both long- and short-term rentals to obtain a permit from the city, contingent on passing a building inspection.
Mr. Fisher, who again is representing the Apartment Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh in a lawsuit against this version, said that although the “most offensive provisions” have been removed, “The way the city went about it was deceptive and lacked proper due process.”
“We don’t oppose a rental registration ordinance,” Mr. Fisher said. “We just oppose the ordinances that they have put forth that have been completely a money grab.”
Mr. Lavelle pushed back on that characterization.
“Given that everything we do has to be done publicly and be done in the light of day, I don't think anything we did can be remotely called deceptive,” the council president said.
He said council members extensively discussed the bill and a public hearing was held.
“At any point they could have weighed in if they had concerns,” he said.
The public hearings focused on the short-term rental aspect of the legislation. A public hearing wasn’t held after the initial language of that ordinance was scrapped and rewritten to combine both short- and long-term rentals.
The September legislation did not outline what fees would be charged for the permits; the fees would be included in a fee schedule that is approved annually with the city budget.
The latest fee schedule upheld the same fees as the 2021 legislation: $16 for application intake, $14 per unit for the inspection plus another $5.50 for travel expenses. The fee schedule does not include fees for the short-term rental permit applications.
Now that the state Supreme Court has ruled the 2021 legislation “moot,” Mr. Fisher said his clients plan to continue to fight the new ordinance.
Mr. Lavelle, during a council meeting Wednesday, called for an executive session to discuss the Supreme Court ruling and the city’s next steps.
The lengthy court battles seem to be a uniquely Pittsburgh problem; while other cities such as Erie have faced legal disputes over their ordinances, both parties have been able to come to an agreement.
Erie settled the matter out of court. The Harrisburg ordinance was enacted in 2011 and updated in 2017, without any legal trouble, according to Mr. Henry. Allentown passed its rental registry ordinance in 1995 and has updated it several times.
All three cities have higher fees than in Pittsburgh.
In Harrisburg, landlords pay $50 a year for a license plus another $75 a year to register the properties.
In Allentown, landlords pay $75 per residential unit. The fee was updated in 2012, according to Ms. Westerman. The city was met with legal challenges, but the courts ruled that the fees were justified to offset the cost of the inspections.
In Erie, landlords pay $40 every other year for the rental permit. If landlords go four years without any violations, then they only pay $30 a cycle.
“[It was] an incentive for the landlord to maintain their property,” Mr. Zimmerman said. The reduction after two cycles was something that came out of discussions with landlords after the lawsuit.
“The most important thing,” Mr. Zimmerman said, “is we were soft-handed. It wasn’t our mindset to go out there and shut down every unit. It was to slowly bring them into code compliance.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.