County Councilman Sam DeMarco filed a lawsuit against County Executive Sara Innamorato on Thursday morning to stop the use of ballot drop-off locations for the upcoming primary election.

In late February, Ms. Innamorato announced the county would be staffing five ballot drop-off locations the two weekends before the April 23 primary.

Very shortly after the announcement, Mr. DeMarco condemned the action and took issue with Ms. Innamorato making the decision without consulting the Board of Elections.

The county’s Board of Elections is made up of three members: Mr. DeMarco, Ms. Innamorato and County Councilwoman Bethany Hallam. Ms. Hallam also was not consulted about the drop-off locations, according to the lawsuit.

Advertise with us

A county spokesperson declined to comment on the lawsuit.

The lawsuit alleges this action is the “textbook definition of political overreach,” and that Ms. Innamorato had “no legal authority” to make the decision without consulting the board.

“The County Executive simply chose to announce the 2024 Satellite Election Offices as if Allegheny County was her own personal fiefdom,” the lawsuit says.

Mr. DeMarco is seeking an emergency injunction. A judge will hear the case Monday morning.

A Board of Elections meeting scheduled for next Wednesday includes “ballot return sites” and “2024 general primary preparations” on its agenda.

Advertise with us

The county opened drop-off points for the general election in 2020 as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. The locations announced last month are different in that they will be staffed, rather than drop boxes.

In his lawsuit, Mr. DeMarco details how the county decided to use those drop boxes in 2020, including that the board of elections formally heard public comments and also voted on it.

In a response to last month’s announcement on the drop-off sites, Mr. DeMarco said that having made this decision without consulting the other board members will “only serve to decrease confidence that Allegheny County’s elections procedures are free from partisan taint.”

Mr. DeMarco also serves as the chairman of the Allegheny County Republican Committee. He is the only Republican member of the Board of Elections.

Pennsylvania’s mail-in voting law, passed in 2019 with support from both Democrats and Republicans, cleared the way for drop boxes.

Advertise with us

But since the 2020 election, concerns about the security of ballot drop boxes have arisen, despite no evidence of widespread fraud or interference in that election.

GOP leaders have claimed that drop-off locations could create the potential for such crimes.

These boxes were permitted during the pandemic under a state Supreme Court ruling.

In an effort to combat that, the Pennsylvania Senate approved a bill in 2022 that eliminated unsupervised ballot drop boxes, which had been placed in county government lobbies, including in Allegheny County.

These boxes were permitted during the pandemic under a state Supreme Court ruling. The proposed locations recently announced by Ms. Innamorato differ from those drop-off boxes because these will be staffed by county employees.

Advertise with us

The issue has popped up across Pennsylvania.

In 2022, four Chester County residents sued to prohibit the county from using drop boxes unless they were physically monitored. The courts ultimately agreed with the residents and ordered the county to staff the drop boxes.

Former County Executive Rich Fitzgerald, a Democrat, also fought the drop boxes, saying that they were unnecessary because voters could use their mailboxes.