Pittsburgh City Council passed Mayor Ed Gainey’s plan to spend $8.3 million in federal grant funding to combat homelessness, despite frustrations over the process of the way the money was allocated.
During a lengthy council meeting last week, multiple members raised concerns about the lack of communication between the mayor’s office and council regarding this plan. The main point of contention was a piece of legislation that would allocate about $6 million of the $8.3 million to the city’s Urban Redevelopment Authority to build affordable rental units specifically for people experiencing or at risk of homelessness.
Councilman Anthony Coghill was the only vote against it.
“I very much disagree with the way they allocated this money,” Mr. Coghill said. “This money was gifted to us, we should have been using it for the immediate need, and not for emergency rental units that are going to be done three or four years from now.”
During last week's meeting, URA officials said that the earliest the rental units would be complete is between 18 and 24 months.
In the development of this plan, the mayor’s team consulted with service providers who said that this use of the funds would be most helpful to alleviate the bottleneck of getting people into housing, Council President Dan Lavelle said Tuesday.
Read More
Mr. Coghill and Councilwoman Deb Gross have recently been pursuing an option to create a village of tiny homes, where people experiencing homelessness could live for a period of time. That plan is currently being held in the planning commission.
“We are working on two separate tracks, and that should not be,” Ms. Gross said during a meeting Tuesday morning. “The administration is working on outreach around these funds and gathering input from social service providers … while council had a concurrent committee for nine months on solutions to homelessness, and there was no communication.”
Last year, council members created a subcommittee to focus specifically on how to combat homelessness in the city. In addition to the tiny homes village, they proposed ideas for more transitional housing, which includes a shelter that would resemble the Second Avenue Commons.
“We’ve come up with four or five different concepts,” Mr. Coghill said. “I’ve yet to see any common sense plan from this administration as to what they’re going to do other than allocate this money.”
Mr. Coghill called for a public meeting with the administration to bring the two groups together to talk about the city’s plans moving forward.
“This is the first time I’ll ever not be voting for federal money that’s granted to us, but I don’t like the way they allocated,” he said. “It could have been done in a much more efficient way.”
Aside from the specific allocations of the plan, council members expressed frustration over their lack of involvement.
Mr. Coghill called the allocation of the funds “irresponsible” and said the lack of communication with council was “frankly, an insult.”
Multiple council members echoed the sentiment from last week that they felt there was little to no communication regarding this funding, even though the homelessness committee was also working on finding solutions for the growing number of people experiencing homelessness in Pittsburgh.
“While we were meeting and presenting our committee on homelessness plan, not one time did this administration share with us their plans for allocating this money,” Mr. Coghill, who chair’s council’s homeless committee, said Tuesday.
He said that it was “just a matter of respect.”
Councilman Bob Charland also shared those frustrations and said that when plans come to council with the money already allocated, it prevents them from doing their jobs.
“If something comes to us and it’s essentially ... Take it how we want you to take it or leave it, then we are in a situation where we’re not able to do what the charter empowers us to do,” he said. “That is something I have a problem with on a fundamental level of separation of powers between the branches of government here.”
If council had not passed the plan Tuesday and insisted on reallocating the money, it would have taken at least 45 days to get reapprove from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, which is providing the funds once a new plan was in place.
That delay was cited by multiple council members in their reasoning for approving the plan, even though they disagreed with the allocations.
Councilman Bobby Wilson said during Tuesday’s meeting that in a meeting he has scheduled with the mayor for later in the day, he will make sure council’s concerns are expressed to Mr. Gainey.
The mayor’s office refused to comment for this story.
Mr. Charland said he was thankful Mr. Wilson would bring concerns to the meeting with Mr. Gainey, but he wanted the administration to work with council as a whole body, rather than individual members.
“I’ve brought my concerns to them, but I have yet to have any productive discussions with the administration,” he said.
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.