After weeks of debate and negotiation, Pittsburgh City Council finally approved the extension of the lease for the police headquarters on the North Side for six more years.
The city agreed on Thursday to pay about $1.3 million a year in rent for the next six years, with an option to buy the building at any point during that time. The 80,000-square-foot building houses the administrative faculty for the Bureau of Police, the evidence storage garage and the Real Time Crime center among other functions of the police department.
But the city didn’t come to this deal easily.
The first iteration of the contract gave the city the authority to purchase the building at the end of the six-year term. Council members pushed back and requested that Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt meet with Ross Development Corp., which owns the building, to see if changes could be made.
The owner was willing to open the purchase option up to any point during the six years, but council members still had concerns.
Even though this agreement includes a nearly $200,000 reduction in the rent rate for the building on Western Avenue, members were apprehensive about locking the city into another six years of renting.
“I think we should try and negotiate a two-year lease,” Council President Theresa Kail-Smith said during a meeting in mid-December.
With the current lease set to expire at the end of January and with very little time to find and then move the headquarters elsewhere, City Council ultimately approved the six-year extension.
“I recommend that we look into [buying] next year, in order to get out of this never-ending lease that I feel like we’re in,” Councilman Anthony Coghill said. “I don’t feel like we really have much of another choice …”
Throughout discussion of the lease extension, Mr. Coghill has raised the idea of issuing a bond to pay for the building. Other members have warned that with projected revenue shortfalls coming in the next few years, the city should consider waiting to take a step like that “ideally after we’ve retired a lot of debt,” as Councilwoman Erika Strassburger said during a previous meeting.
Current budget projections show 2025 and 2026 will be lean years in terms of the city’s revenues, with the expiration of federal COVID-19 relief funding and increased debt service payments.
It is not currently clear how much acquiring the building would cost, but should the city choose to make that move, the property would have to be assessed by someone for the city and an assessor for the landlord. They who would come together to determine a price.
Some council members have estimated it would cost around $20 million to buy the building.
The city of Pittsburgh has been renting this building for the police headquarters for more than 20 years and so far has spent about $27 million in rent. To the dismay of multiple council members, none of the rent paid over those years will be applied to the purchase.
“It really does feel like we’re being held hostage to the building,” Councilwoman Deb Gross previously said.
But Jake Pawlak, the director of the Office of Management and Budget, countered that not pursuing this path and instead looking for another location at this moment would be “a greater price” to the city.
Multiple council members along with Mr. Pawlak noted that this was an inherited problem and a direct result of the city’s mismanagement of its budget in the early 2000s. The former police headquarters, which is now a parklet, was located on First Avenue in Downtown and required substantial renovations.
The city, which was about to enter state financial oversight under Act 47 at that time, didn’t have the funds to renovate the former site, so the building was sold to PNC and the police headquarters moved to its current location on the North Side.
“My hope would be that we never find ourselves in this kind of situation [again],” outgoing Councilman Bruce Kraus said Thursday. “We all agree this was not our finest hour in terms of spending public dollars.”
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.