Efforts to ban furs and horse-drawn carriage rides in Pittsburgh stalled Wednesday in City Council, while a ban on the French delicacy foie gras moved forward.

Council members Bruce Kraus and Erika Strassburger introduced three pieces of legislation last week that sought to ban the sale and manufacturing of furs, the use of horse-drawn carriages, and foie gras.

Foie gras is made from the fattened liver of a duck or goose. The liver is typically fattened by force-feeding the animals. That process “often causes the animals significant injury and illness,” according to the legislation.

There are a number of restaurants in the city that have served the dish, though many of them — like Altius on Mount Washington and Eleven in the Strip District — have menus that change with the seasons. Neither currently have it on their menus, according to their websites.

Advertise with us

The ban got preliminary approval during Wednesday’s Council meeting. Council members Deb Gross and Anthony Coghill abstained from the vote. Council President Theresa Kail-Smith voted against it. If given full approval during Council’s meeting next week, enforcement would begin 11 days after Mayor Ed Gainey signs the bill into law.

Restaurants that continue to serve the dish could face fines of up to $500 per violation.

Legislation to ban furs and horse-drawn carriages was postponed three weeks. Under Council rules, those bills would now have to be reintroduced next year to be considered.

“Millions of animals” endure “tremendous suffering” each year for their fur to be harvested and sold, according to the fur legislation.

The bill would have banned the sale of furs, unless they were sold by a nonprofit organization or in a second-hand store. It would also provide an exemption for the use of fur products for religious or cultural purposes.

Advertise with us

Multiple city residents opposed the ban in public comments to Council, including Carl Herrmann, who owns Carl Herrmann Furs on Smithfield Street Downtown.

“Having been in the business 124 years, I look forward to being in business for another 124 years,” he said Wednesday. “Weather permitting of course.”

Michael Brown of the Natural Fibers Alliance, a group that promotes the use of “natural and sustainable materials in clothing,” said banning fur clothing “lacks reasonable grounds and exceeds the limitations set by state statute.”

He also said the raising of animals for their furs is “no different from animals raised for food.”

The final piece of legislation would have banned the use of horse-drawn carriages within city limits. Carriage rides are “incompatible” with an urban environment, can lead to an increased risk of injury to drivers and riders, and are “inhumane” the horses, the legislation said.

Advertise with us

Humane Action Pittsburgh, a local nonprofit that assisted in drafting all three bills, said they addressed “some of the most egregious forms of animal abuse being supported in Pittsburgh. These ordinances will protect animals without undue harm to businesses or the public."

“Local legislation can be a vital stepping stone for the progression of animal welfare goals at the state and federal levels,” Kate Barton, an attorney with Animal Wellness Action and the Center for Humane Economy, said in a statement. “[Humane Action Pittsburgh] already successfully led Pittsburgh to ban the circus and to pass the first retail sales ban in the state of puppy mill-sourced dogs. These new proposals are along those same lines in putting limits on commercial enterprises to not only help to protect animals but also further larger environmental, health, and public safety aims.”

It was not immediately clear why action on the fur and carriage ride bills was postponed during Wednesday’s meeting, or if Ms. Strassburger intended to reintroduce them next year. Mr. Kraus is retiring at the end of this year.

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com