Four candidates in two critical Allegheny County races used the last week before Election Day to make final pitches to voters and get supporters to the polls, in elections with huge implications for local government that have drawn national attention as early bellwethers for the 2024 presidential contest.
Members of the county GOP held a “door knocking day of action” Saturday across the county to support Joe Rockey, the Republican nominee for county executive. Gov. Josh Shapiro campaigned in Pittsburgh on Saturday for Sara Innamorato, the Democratic nominee for executive. And a rally was planned for her in McKeesport on Sunday with other party leaders, including U.S. Sen. John Fetterman and Lt. Gov. Austin Davis.
County Executive Rich Fitzgerald, a term-limited Democrat, is leaving office after 12 years, guaranteeing a new face in the county’s top elected office. It will either be Ms. Innamorato, a staunchly progressive former state representative, or Mr. Rockey, a political newcomer and former PNC executive who has run as a moderate.
It has become a political battle not only over local issues but national ones, too, and could have lasting implications into the 2024 elections and beyond.
Also on the ballot is a bitter rematch between candidates for district attorney who already faced off just five months ago. Matt Dugan, the county’s progressive former chief public defender, won the May Democratic primary against longtime incumbent DA Stephen A. Zappala Jr. But Mr. Zappala won the Republican nomination as a write-in candidate, setting up Round Two for the Nov. 7 general election.
That race has attracted national attention — and money — as the latest contest between criminal justice reformers and more traditional prosecutors. Polling has shown crime and public safety to be the top issue for county voters.
With Democrats enjoying a two-to-one voter registration in Allegheny County, many assumed a November victory for Ms. Innamorato was a foregone conclusion after she won the primary. But local political observers have credited Mr. Rockey with making it a competitive race.
“He’s run the exact kind of campaign he would need to, to have a shot at winning,” said Mike Butler, a longtime Democratic political analyst.
Mr. Rockey raised more than twice as much money as Ms. Innamorato since the primary, using the cash to put himself in voters’ living rooms on their TV screens early and often. Mr. Rockey’s campaign has spent almost $1.4 million on advertising, in addition to about $718,000 by an outside group supporting him, according to AdImpact, which tracks political advertising. Ms. Innamorato’s campaign has spent less than $450,00 on the airwaves.
Ads for Mr. Rockey have touted his policy plans for kitchen-table issues and highlighted Ms. Innamorato’s former membership with the far-left Democratic Socialists of America. Her ads have increasingly emphasized national issues, especially Mr. Rockey’s refusal to take a public position on abortion.
With Mr. Rockey consistently branding himself as a centrist focused on jobs and public safety, and Ms. Innamorato hoping to continue a years-long wave of progressive victories in Western Pennsylvania, the results will help answer questions that are relevant to both next year’s presidential race and local politics in the years ahead: Are there limits to progressive gains even in Democratic bastions like Allegheny County? And can Republicans push back those gains by nominating candidates like Mr. Rockey, who paint their Democratic opponents as extremists while avoiding the political pitfalls of social issues and election denial that have doomed so many GOP candidates in the Trump era?
“Reflecting on our campaign, I am moved thinking about the milestones we have passed in 10 months,” Mr. Rockey said last week on social media. “We set out to start a conversation.”
It was a conversation about “hope” that became conversations about public safety, jobs, and “common sense government that rejects extremes in favor of a moderate, responsible policy,” Mr. Rockey said.
Ms. Innamorato has said abortion rights and protecting democracy are “on the ballot,” while often speaking about local issues in less specific terms than Mr. Rockey. Her campaign website focuses on things like the “root cause” of issues like violent crime and homelessness.
“It’s about people-centered policies,” she said at a candidate meet-and-greet Thursday evening. “It’s about making sure that we are pulling up more seats to the table of county government. It means that we are building a county for us all.”
The election is “about preserving rights,” like the right to vote and reproductive rights, Ms. Innamorato said.
The only public poll of the races, released last week, showed both contests in a statistical dead heat.
At the same candidate meet-and-greet in Larimer, Mr. Dugan said his election was “going to be close.”
“We went and did something extraordinary in our primary,” he said. “We took down [a] 24-year Democratic incumbent. It was exciting, it was fun, but now we’ve seen that we’re up against a true machine: someone who is not willing and not ready to let go of power.”
That same night, Ms. Innamorato noted the flurry of TV ads attacking her and her running mate.
“Who here has seen a negative TV ad about myself or Mr. Dugan?” she asked the crowd.
Nearly everyone raised their hands.
Ads from Mr. Zappala’s campaign, which is now being run by a constellation of longtime Republican operatives, have portrayed Mr. Dugan as soft on crime. Mr. Dugan’s ads have attacked Mr. Zappala’s record, saying he hasn’t done enough to reform the criminal justice system and won’t protect reproductive rights.
The tone of the ad campaign has become increasingly bitter — from a Zappala spot claiming that Mr. Dugan told a rape victim to “shut up,” to multiple Dugan ads claiming that Mr. Zappala jailed a woman who had a miscarriage.
“It’s important to say where the money is coming from,” Ms. Innamorato said Thursday.
Some of the pro-Rockey ads have been aired by a group called Save Allegheny County, which received some of its funding from the Commonwealth Leaders Fund, one of the top conservative political groups in Pennsylvania. Commonwealth’s top contributor is Jeffrey Yass, a GOP mega donor and Pennsylvania’s richest man.
Mr. Zappala’s campaign has also received at least $100,000 from a PAC with ties to Commonwealth.
“You’ve seen the race that this has turned into,” Mr. Dugan said Thursday. “One filled with lies and negative ads and fear mongering. They know that they’re losing this race right now.”
But Mr. Dugan has benefited from his own gusher of outside money: Almost his entire primary and general election campaigns have been paid for by the Pennsylvania Justice and Public Safety PAC, a group for which the billionaire liberal mega donor George Soros is the only contributor. Mr. Soros has spent almost $2 million trying to get Mr. Dugan elected as the county’s top prosecutor.
In an interview with the Post-Gazette last week, Mr. Zappala pointed to that money and said he’s proud to have most of his financial support from local labor unions and other groups.
“It wasn’t a local campaign,” Mr. Zappala said of Mr. Dugan’s primary campaign. “It was a national campaign with national people behind it.”
Both DA candidates have also spent big on the airwaves. Mr. Dugan’s campaign has dropped almost $700,000 on advertising during the general election, according to AdImpact, all of it paid for by Mr. Soros. Mr. Zappala’s campaign has spent about $615,000.
The contentious campaign even spilled into the festivities of Halloween last week.
“Matt Dugan is dressing up for Halloween as someone who gives a damn about victims rights,” Mr. Zappala said on social media. “He’s always been on the side of the accused criminal. That won’t change if he’s the District Attorney. Don’t be fooled.”
Mr. Dugan’s campaign replied with a letter signed by nine local advocacy groups asking to meet with him and and Mr. Zappala to discuss the prosecution of sexual assault and rape cases.
“It has come to our attention that the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office has a practice of regularly declining to pursue charges in cases of sexual assault where the assaliant and the victim had a prior relationship,” the letter said.
Mr. Dugan, who resigned as chief public defender after winning the primary, urged his supporters Thursday to vote for change.
“I’ve worked for 16 years in a system led by Steve Zappala,” he said. “I have seen day in and day out the failures of that system.”
Mr. Zappala stood by his record.
“I’ve lived in a fishbowl for my entire career,” Mr. Zappala told the Post-Gazette. “I’ve got nothing that we’re ashamed of, nothing we want to hide.”
Much of the local Democratic establishment — including Mr. Fetterman, Mr. Davis, Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey, and U.S. Reps. Summer Lee and Chris DeLuzio — is backing Mr. Dugan, as are some labor unions.
Mr. Zappala, meanwhile, has received support from unions representing both county and city police officers. The incumbent has argued in the homestretch of his campaign that Mr. Gainey’s administration hasn’t let cops do their jobs amid concerns about Downtown crime — something the mayor has dismissed as election-season grandstanding by Mr. Zappala.
In the county executive race, both candidates have jockeyed for support from organized labor.
Mr. Rockey received endorsements from unions representing higher-wage, skilled workers such as the Pennsylvania District Council of the Laborers International Union. Ms. Innamorato has gotten support from trade unions and service-sector unions.
The off-year elections are also an early test of whether Republicans can get their voters to cast ballots by mail, after years of lies by former President Donald Trump and his supporters that they are rife with fraud. Local GOP leaders, convinced that the party’s resistance to mail voting is an electoral liability, have urged voters to start banking their votes earlier in the campaign season by requesting and submitting mail ballots.
But county data shows that’s easier said than done: Of the more than 141,000 mail ballots requested in Allegheny County, about 108,000 were for Democrats, compared to only 22,000 for Republicans.
More than 89,000 mail ballots had already been returned as of Friday, about 71,000 from registered Democrats and about 13,000 from Republicans.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.