Pittsburgh’s mayor and its top prosecutor are locked in a political war of words when it comes to crime.

The fight between Mayor Ed Gainey and Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. has become something of a proxy for Mr. Zappala’s reelection campaign, less than six weeks before Election Day. It’s also left Pittsburgh residents worried about crime caught in the middle.

The debate began late last week, when Matt Dugan, the Democratic nominee for DA, accused Mr. Zappala, a lifelong Democrat running on the Republican ticket, of ducking his responsibility to keep Pittsburghers safe. Mr. Dugan, a progressive criminal justice reformer and the county’s former chief public defender, beat Mr. Zappala in the May Democratic primary. But the two are set for a November rematch after the longtime incumbent won the GOP nomination with write-in votes. 

“It’s time we have a district attorney who accepts the responsibility of tackling public safety in Downtown Pittsburgh,” Mr. Dugan said last Friday. “Law enforcement begins with the DA’s office. And come January, we look forward to leading that effort.

Advertise with us

Mr. Zappala quickly fired back, saying Mr. Dugan doesn’t have the experience to be the county’s top prosecutor. 

“Matt Dugan says a lot of things that he wants to do that are simply outside of the purview of the district attorney’s office,” Mr. Zappala said. “For many of the policies he proposes, he should consider running for an office that can actually do the things he proposes. The district attorney’s office is a law enforcement office, not a social service agency.”

But Mr. Zappala went a step further by taking aim at Mr. Gainey. He said the mayor and city officials are “not allowing police to do their jobs, which is causing the spike in crime Downtown.”

Mr. Gainey told reporters this week that he’s willing to have a serious conversation with Mr. Zappala about crime Downtown and elsewhere. But he said the DA needs to accept that crime has occurred on his watch, too.

“I’m not going to go back and forth with the [district attorney],” Mr. Gainey said. “The DA’s been there for 20 years. It is what it is. The only time I’ve heard him speak is right now. … There are different issues that he could be attacking right now, to bring peace to this city instead of violence.”

Advertise with us

The tension has been building. In a now-deleted video briefing from mid-August in which Mr. Zappala provided details of multiple ongoing criminal cases, he specifically criticized Mr. Gainey and his administration, as well as Pittsburgh Public Schools, for not working with the district attorney's office.

And things could still get hotter. Mr. Zappala’s office this week ​​requested more documents and information from the Gainey administration for his probe of a contract that led to a controversial police staffing study released earlier this year.

The mayor's spokesperson called Mr. Zappala's request an instance in which he was "once again... busy playing politics." 

The back and forth is coming amid colliding dynamics in both politics and public safety. 

Business leaders and others have voiced growing alarm about crime and homelessness Downtown, leading Mr. Gainey and County Executive Rich Fitzgerald to convene stakeholders to address the concerns this week. Meanwhile, Mr. Zappala is increasingly adopting a tone on crime more common to Republican campaigns, warning in his first TV ad of the general election that “the same extremists who created” crime in Philadelphia and San Francisco “want Pittsburgh to be their next social justice experiment.”

Advertise with us

And along with Sara Innamorato, the Democratic nominee aiming to succeed the outgoing Mr. Fitzgerald as county executive, Mr. Dugan is hoping to join Mr. Gainey as the latest progressive to win a powerful elected office in Western Pennsylvania. 

Data from the city’s Department of Public Safety shows major crimes — such as homicide, robbery and theft — dropped by 4% across Pittsburgh in the first seven months of 2023, compared to the same period last year. But while the city’s data shows an overall decline in crime — including homicides dropping by a third compared to the same time last year — Downtown and the South Side have remained epicenters of shootings and other violence, The Post-Gazette reported in August.

Academics and political observers watching the feud between Mr. Gainey and Mr. Zappala said it reflects a typical environment around crime and other issues during an election season. They said it’s unlikely to affect day-to-day public safety, but that it’s difficult to know if it will have a longer-term impact.

David Harris, a law professor at the University of Pittsburgh, said it’s not unusual for political candidates like Mr. Zappala to point the finger at others for crime. But Mr. Zappala and Mr. Gainey, who oversees the city’s police force, both have roles to play in public safety, he said.

“What we should be seeing is a unified strategy from police, the prosecution, the health department and other agencies… to ensure [the] safety of all members of the public,” Mr. Harris said. 

Advertise with us

The spat also shows voters that they have very different choices in the race for DA, Mr. Harris said. 

Joe Mistick, who was chief of staff under former Pittsburgh Mayor Sophie Masloff, said having such clearly different options for DA is good for voters.

“For the voter, this is easy. The lines aren’t blurred,” said Mr. Mistick, a law professor at Duquesne University. “You have Matt Dugan and his progressive policies… and Zappala, who I’d call a ‘law and order Democrat.’”

There might be more productive relationships between Mr. Gainey, Mr. Zappala, and other law enforcement officials and staffers if the top elected officials were on the same page, said Jason Gravel, a criminal justice professor at Temple University. But that’s true of any elected officials working on policy across multiple offices, he said. 

“I don’t know that it makes the city less safe, it depends if that disagreement leads to diverting resources that should be allowed for prosecuting crime,” Mr. Gravel said. “I think a lot of this is kind of political posturing.”

-Staff writer Hallie Lauer contributed reporting.