A week after a video briefing in which he described the targets of a high-profile May 2022 shooting Downtown as “criminals” despite not yet being convicted, Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen Zappala Jr. is seeking a gag order to restrict pretrial publicity in the case.
Mr. Zappala removed the video from the Allegheny County District Attorney’s YouTube page earlier this week following criticism that his outspokenness regarding the case was unprofessional and may have violated legal ethics rules.
The Aug.16 briefing discussed a notorious May 2022 drive-by shooting near the corner of Fourth Avenue and Stanwix Street Downtown, in which bullets struck and killed 18-month-old De’Avry Thomas.
The infant was strapped into his car seat in the back of a Jeep Wrangler driven by his mother when Markez Anger and Londell Falconer Jr. fired shots into the vehicle, purportedly aiming to target Hezekiah Nixon and Tylajae Allen.
Anger and Falconer Jr. were convicted of first-degree murder this June, but Nixon and Allen were arrested last August in connection with a separate incident of gun violence in California-Kirkbride.
While Nixon and Allen have not been convicted, Mr. Zappala referred to the two men as “criminals” in the video, which included images of evidence and detailed information on the case.
According to the motion for a gag order filed Wednesday, Chief Trial Deputy District Attorney William Petulla responded to claims from the defense attorney that the briefing will “have a negative impact on the jury pool.” He argued that there was no evidence of prejudice, but because neither Nixon’s nor Allen’s case has been given a definitive trial date, a gag order would be appropriate “in an abundance of caution.”
Citing the commonwealth’s Rules for Professional Conduct, he wrote that the opposing counsel “may make extrajudicial statements referring to the objected-to statements,” and that these could possibly influence the trial.
“The commonwealth further submits that any reference to the defendant’s character by both parties should be limited to the judicial process,” Mr. Petulla wrote in the motion.
Defense attorney Casey White said Mr. Zappala’s remarks were “concerning and irresponsible,” and that by filing for a gag order, the district attorney is “acknowledging he made a mistake.”
A spokesperson from the District Attorney’s office confirmed the video had been removed from its website and YouTube page, and said that “the pleading speaks for itself.”
On August 15, Mr. Zappala’s office announced the first of a series of video briefings in what he said was an effort to facilitate the public’s access to information about issues and cases “that have an immediate threat to our public safety,” according to a release.
Mr. Zappala, who is running for a seventh term in office, lost the Democratic primary in May to Matt Dugan, the county’s former chief public defender. Mr. Zappala is now seeking office as a Republican following a massive write-in campaign.
Michael Korsh: mkorsh@post-gazette.com; Neena Hagen: nhagen@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.