Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald has vetoed legislation County Council passed this month to tweak the appointment process for the county’s chief assessment officer and give lawmakers more authority over the position.

The bill, which Council passed by a 9-6 vote on July 11, would make multiple changes to the assessment officer job, which helps collect data and calculate property assessments throughout the county.

It would require that the county manager submit a nomination to Council, a majority of which would need to approve. Currently, the county manager has full control of who the chief assessment officer is. It would let Council make its own pick for the position if it sits vacant for 90 days. It would allow Council to remove the chief assessment officer by a majority vote for cause or lack of qualifications. And it would require the official to provide more information about assessments and taxation to both the County Council president and the State Tax Equalization Board.

The veto Thursday is at least the fifth that Mr. Fitzgerald has issued since taking office in January 2012. A term-limited Democrat, he is leaving office after this year.

Advertise with us

In his veto letter, Mr. Fitzgerald said he nixed the bill because it violates the separation of powers between the executive and legislative branches laid out in the county’s charter and administrative code. He also criticized Council’s move to let it remove the chief assessment officer for cause as “technically deficient.”

That is, in part, because “cause” is not defined in county code, Mr. Fitzgerald wrote. There also is no precedent for a county legislative body conducting a due-process hearing for someone appointed by the executive branch, he said. The bill would also create new reporting requirements that the chief assessment officer wouldn’t be able to fulfill, he wrote.

County Council President Patrick Catena blasted the veto in a statement Thursday. He said he introduced the bill last December after problems with the current property assessment process. Many property owners in the Strip District and Downtown have challenged the county, claiming the underlying data used in recent assessments is inaccurate. Common Pleas Court Judge Alan Hertzberg has said Allegheny County’s Office of Property Assessment was “cooking the books’” on data submitted to the State Tax Equalization Board.

The so-called “common level ratio” data submitted to that board helps determine assessments. The county has denied deliberately submitting any incorrect data.

Mr. Catena said the bill is needed partly because a chief assessment officer who worked for the county and gave inaccurate “common level ratio” data was not qualified for the position. They were a computer programmer, not a trained assessments professional, Mr. Catena said.

Advertise with us

“Our county’s administration essentially put the fox in charge of the henhouse, and there was literally no meaningful oversight of the [common level ratio] calculation process as a result,” Mr. Catena said. “This bill is designed to prevent this type of malfeasance from ever taking place again.”

Amie Downs, a spokesperson for Mr. Fitzgerald, called Mr. Catena’s comments “inappropriate and beneath him as a county official. They do not deserve a response.”

“This legislation is another attempt to take authority that is not given to the legislative branch in the Home Rule Charter and circumvents the voters,” Ms. Downs said in a statement. “That is why it was vetoed. This administration has gone 12 years with no tax increase to county taxpayers. In that same time, property values have increased 2.5 times over what they were in 2012. The County Executive fought the last court reassessment because he understood the impact it would have on taxpayers. ... Mr. Catena also fails to acknowledge that, more recently, the County Executive approved legislation that extended the appeals deadline and returned today, with his signature, legislation that is intended to ensure that all appeals get heard.”

During the July 11 meeting, Council members Jack Betkowski, Sam DeMarco, Suzanne Filiaggi, Nicholas Futules, Bob Macey, and DeWitt Walton opposed the bill. Some said there were too many unanswered questions about the legislation. Mr. Walton called it a serious overreach by the legislative branch.

Two-thirds of Council members present, or 10 out of 15 if the full body votes, are needed to override a veto. Mr. Catena said in an interview Friday that he would discuss an override vote with his colleagues before they reconvene in August. He wouldn’t say whether he had the additional vote needed to override Mr. Fitzgerald’s veto, but said there would be a vote.

“It’s a sad day of affairs that we have to involve the courts in this assessments debacle, because of the county’s malfeasance,” Mr. Catena said, “but here we are.”