There were few problems and in many cases not a lot of voters Tuesday as Allegheny County residents went to the polls to pick nominees for county executive and other local races.
While the county executive race was the biggest draw in Western Pennsylvania, other offices on the ballot included Allegheny County district attorney and county council. There also were elections for school boards across the region, as well as a slew of municipal and judicial primaries.
The problems were largely the kind that crop up every six months in the business of running elections: late-opening polling places or a shortage of workers. All were quickly corrected.
Acting Secretary of the Commonwealth Al Schmidt, whose department oversees Pennsylvania elections, said in a statement after polls closed that the voting ”ran smoothly” with just a handful of “routine issues” for local officials to handle.
But many voters just stayed home. A county elections official had forecast turnout of about 30%. By late Tuesday afternoon, county spokeswoman Amie M. Downs said that, “anecdotally, turnout appears to be low.” Final turnout figures weren’t yet available Tuesday evening.
“When you have an election where the biggest race is county executive, it doesn’t turn people out” like a presidential or U.S. Senate race would, said Brack Barr of Chartiers, a longtime poll worker at the Ingram Borough Building
Dave Baker, 67, said he went to breakfast Tuesday with 12 of his friends. He said he was the only one who voted.
“So many of us feel like things won’t change no matter who we vote for,” said Mr. Baker, 67, a Republican who said he supported retired PNC executive Joe Rockey for county executive — because there were “no other options” on the GOP ticket.
There were so few voters at the Bethel Park Volunteer Fire Company that candidates standing outside to meet those coming in joked about what to do with all their leftover flyers.
Jack Peters, an electrical contractor in Bethel Park, said there weren't a lot of choices at the top of the ballot. Mr. Rockey was the only Republican candidate for county executive.
"There's not much for us to vote for if you're Republican," Mr. Peters said. "I'll have to wait for the main election to really give my two cents worth."
Amid Pennsylvania’s huge expansion of mail voting since 2020, some made sure to vote in person, as they have for years. They included John Studeny, a 93-year-old Bloomfield Democrat and retired printer who said he has never missed an election.
Thomas Donaldson, 67, a Swissvale retiree, showed off a faded voter registration card issued in 1996. He and his wife Karen said they backed more “enlightened” and “progressive” candidates — often women.
“I come from strong women, strong stock,” Ms. Donaldson, 70, said outside the Swissvale Senior Center.
At the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh, located in state Rep. Sara Innamorato’s home turf of Lawrenceville, optometrist Danielle Staresinic said it’s important to vote. Ms. Innamorato entered election day as a leading Democratic candidate for county executive.
“This is how you keep democracy going,” said Ms. Staresinic, 51. “You show up and vote.”
For those who did show up, personal relationships figured into some of their voting decisions.
Patricia Faloon, a Democrat who has lived in Beechview for 67 years, said she voted for Michael Lamb for county executive. She said she used to live on the same street as the Pittsburgh city controller’s family.
"They have a history of being good politicians," Ms. Faloon, a retired clown-for-hire and performer at children's parties and events, said of the Lamb family, which includes former U.S. Rep. Conor Lamb, D-Mt. Lebanon.
"They're a good family," she said.
Diane Muscia, a Democrat who has lived in Beechview for five decades, said her main reason for casting a ballot Tuesday was to back City Councilman Anthony Coghill in the race for county treasurer. The incumbent treasurer, John Weinstein, ran for county executive. Ms. Muscia said she has known Mr. Coghill for many years, and they used to be neighbors.
That was similar to the reasons that some residents in Kennedy Township gave for supporting Mr. Weinstein for county executive. Campaign signs for the Kennedy native son littered front yards and framed the walkway to the polling place at Williams Middle School.
“I know John and I trust him,” said Roberta Dalesandro, a retired Democrat who lives in the town and said she’s known the Weinstein family for more than 50 years. Mr. Weinstein’s father Mel is a longtime local government official and power broker.
Such sentiments crossed party lines. George Dudash, a registered Republican who sits on the Montour school board, also voted for Mr. Weinstein. Mr. Dudash grew up in Kennedy and said he has known Mr. Weinstein “all his life.”
“He’s always supported me, so I support him,” Mr. Dudash said. “He’s always interested in listening and he will think creatively to find ways to solve problems.”
Among the issues voters cited were crime and education.
Ms. Muscia, who works part-time for PNC, said she’s concerned about public safety, especially Downtown and in Beechview.
"Our next-door neighbor had her [license] plates stolen and put on a stolen car," Ms. Muscia said. "I've been here for 50 years, and I've never seen stuff like that."
Tara Lovett of Overbrook, a behavioral health specialist, said mental health and Downtown economic development were top-of-mind as she voted.
And Liz Marks, also of Overbrook, listed abortion and health care as top issues for her in supporting Ms. Innamorato and incumbent at-large County Councilwoman Bethany Hallam.
"In general terms, when it comes to reproductive health and rights, I align with them," said Ms. Marks, 21, a Starbucks barista. "And I have a lot of health problems, as do my friends, so it's a major issue for us.”
In Shadyside, Fadwa Brady, who works for Carnegie Mellon, said she wants to see more money spent on public education and more schools for children with special needs.
Ms. Brady, 45, said it doesn’t matter whether candidates are Republicans or Democrats — as long as they listen to voters.
“They should be authentic enough to persevere and fight for what they bring to the table from the beginning,” she said.
While many registered Democrats and Republicans stayed home, a group of independent voters went to their local polling places —even though they couldn’t cast ballots in the major-party primaries under Pennsylvania’s “closed primary” rules.
“I don’t always vote the straight party line, but this allows me to stake my claim,” said Camila Rivera-Tinsley, of Swisshelm Park.
“It’s really important that we have a third party and that we have options,” Ms. Rivera-Tinsley, 44, said outside the Jackson Black Community Center. “If we don’t, we will never get to have that glimpse of progress.”
And some Libertarian Party members, who also had no say in picking the Democratic and Republican nominees Tuesday, took the election day opportunity to gather signatures for their candidates at a polling place in South Fayette — and tout their platform of lowering taxes and overhauling the criminal justice system.
Allegheny County, Pennsylvania’s second-most populous county after Philadelphia, has the most registered Libertarians in the state.
As David Soltesz, the vice chair of the county’s Libertarian Party, said at the Fairview Sunset Room: “We’re not an effective democracy if we don’t provide voters with as many options as possible.”
Maddie Aiken, Steve Bohnel, Neena Hagen, John Hayes, Adam Smeltz, Mary Ann Thomas and Hanna Webster contributed to this report.
Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.