After just two supporters gave his campaign more than $200,000, Allegheny County executive candidate John Weinstein said it posed “absolutely no conflict” of interest because they “don’t do any business” with the county.

But Mr. Weinstein’s relationship with a Pittsburgh financial services executive is a different story.

Robert Fragasso’s firm bills Allegheny County more than $30,000 a year to manage about $6 million worth of investments on behalf of retirees, public records show.

And he starred in one of Mr. Weinstein’s TV commercials earlier this spring, when Mr. Weinstein was dominating the airwaves.

Advertise with us

As the longtime county treasurer, Mr. Weinstein is president of the retirement board, one of seven board members who award contracts and oversee the roughly $1 billion county pension fund  — including payments to investment managers. Both Mr. Fragasso, the chairman and CEO of Fragasso Financial Advisors, and his company’s name appear in at least two Weinstein campaign ads. In one 30-second spot, he calls Mr. Weinstein “a caring, honest, good person who really cares about what happens in our county.”

Mr. Fragasso also made a pair of relatively small campaign contributions to Mr. Weinstein, a Democrat, years ago.

The mix of government business and political support does not appear to violate any laws, experts told the Post-Gazette. But it’s not a good look, said Pat Christmas, chief policy officer at the Committee of Seventy, a Philadelphia-based good-government group.

“There should be a near-firewall on political activity between contractors and public officials to guard against perceived conflicts of interest and actual fraud,” Mr. Christmas said. “Just the appearance of a cozy relationship between a business interest and government officials can dampen public trust.”

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission limits political contributions, including vaguely defined non-monetary items “of value,” from certain registered investment advisors to government officials and political candidates. Under the so-called Pay-to-Play Rule, Mr. Fragasso’s TV appearances are likely permissible, according to a former SEC enforcement official.

Advertise with us

“You could debate whether it’s in the spirit of the rule, but I think it probably would be viewed as OK,” said the former official, who is now a partner at a Washington law firm and spoke on condition of anonymity to avoid affecting their employer’s interests.

Mr. Fragasso participated in the TV ads as a volunteer after approaching Mr. Weinstein because they share concerns about public safety Downtown, Weinstein campaign spokesperson Lisa Edmonds said. The Fragasso firm is located in the Golden Triangle.

“Mr. Weinstein and Mr. Fragasso follow the letter of the law,” Ms. Edmonds said. Their relationship developed from their work together at Animal Friends, an animal welfare nonprofit in Ohio Township, she said.

Mr. Fragasso “believes in good-government leadership,” Ms. Edmonds added, and “knows [Mr. Weinstein] is a true advocate for animals and the animal welfare movement.”

The SEC generally caps campaign contributions from investment advisors at $350 per candidate when a race involves a government entity with which the advisor does business and they’re eligible to vote. Donations of one’s time typically don’t count as non-monetary contributions, said the former SEC official.

Advertise with us

“There’s a real tension between the [Pay-to-Play] Rule and the First Amendment,” the former official said. 

“The courts have been protective of First Amendment [free] speech in this context,” although it’s unusual for an investment advisor to be in a campaign ad, the former official added.

Put in place 12 years ago to keep political contributors from effectively buying influence and government contracts, the Pay-to-Play Rule has withstood repeated challenges to its legality, including arguments over free speech.

Mr. Fragasso said in an interview that his firm began managing part of the county pension fund about a decade ago. That work started when Mr. Weinstein looked to bring on more local, independent investment managers, Mr. Fragasso said Monday.

He said two SEC audits of his firm came back “very clean.” 

Advertise with us

The retirement board unanimously picked his firm as part of a public process, and fees paid to the group follow a normal formula, Mr. Fragasso said. He also said an independent consultant for the retirement board reviews pension managers every year.

The investments Mr. Fragasso’s firm managed saw a 7.4% average annual return over the past five years, underperforming the 9.82% annual average for the S&P 500 during the same period, according to a February report to the pension board. The county pension fund overall underperformed the market by a larger margin, with 5.17% average annual return over those five years.

The SEC doesn’t comment on specific organizations, individuals or situations, an agency spokesman said. 

“My endorsement of John came from my almost 25 years of working with [him] on a nonprofit animal shelter board. He has done tremendous work,” Mr. Fragasso said, praising Mr. Weinstein as dedicated and honest. “I felt very comfortable recommending him on that basis, but it certainly wasn’t because of something eight or nine years ago.”

His support for Mr. Weinstein includes two campaign contributions of $250 apiece in 2014 and 2018, according to financial filings. Mr. Fragasso said he’s not concerned about any appearance of a conflict of interest, but expects that “anyone can make something out of anything if they want to.” His firm has a compliance officer and is careful to abide by regulations, he said.

Advertise with us

“If what I just described to you is a problem, then no one is going to help anyone for any reason,” Mr. Fragasso said, referring to his relationships with the county and with Mr. Weinstein.

The Weinstein campaign spent only about $4,000 to air the 30-second spot that features Mr. Fragasso speaking by himself, according to AdImpact, which tracks political advertising. That ad appeared from late March to early April and spotlights the men’s leadership at Animal Friends.

In a more recent spot that aired for roughly the same cost, Mr. Fragasso is among three men giving testimonials. To date, the two commercials account for only about 1% of Mr. Weinstein’s spending on TV and radio ads, according to AdImpact.

Six candidates are seeking the Democratic nomination in the May 16 primary election. Of the four airing TV ads, Mr. Weinstein has spent the most on airtime — about $814,000 as of Monday. Trial lawyer Dave Fawcett, a former County Council member, has spent almost $595,000, while state Rep. Sara Innamorato, D-Lawrenceville, and Pittsburgh City Controller Michael Lamb have spent about $303,000 and $70,000, respectively.

The totals don’t include ad spending by outside political groups or reservations for future ads. 

Advertise with us

The Democratic nominee is expected to face Republican Joe Rockey, the sole GOP candidate, in the November general election. Outgoing County Executive Rich Fitzgerald, a Democrat first elected in 2011, is term-limited.

Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz