The Allegheny County retirement board moved Thursday to audit the management and performance of the county’s roughly $1 billion pension fund.

John Weinstein, the county treasurer who chairs the retirement board, was absent when members voted 4-0 to solicit bids for the independent audit sought by outgoing county Executive Rich Fitzgerald. Board member Frank DiCristofaro abstained, saying the board has two other reviews already in process.

But Mr. Fitzgerald said the new audit would be different — assessing specifically whether the county follows financial best practices to manage investments on behalf of county retirees.

“This is really an audit to say, ‘Are we doing it the best way? Do we have too many [money] managers?’” said Mr. Fitzgerald, who is also a board member. “My suspicion is that we do and that we’re sending too much money [in] fees to management companies.

Advertise with us

“And I want an expert — an independent expert — that can tell us if we’re doing it in the best way,” he added.

Mr. Fitzgerald has pushed the audit effort for a couple years, but “we’ve been dragging this out,” he said. “I heard Chairman Weinstein talk about [it]; he never really did it.”

Mr. Weinstein couldn’t be reached for comment Thursday. He is widely seen as the front-runner among six candidates for the Democratic nomination for county executive in the May 16 primary election.

After the Post-Gazette tried to contact Mr. Weinstein directly, retirement office Manager Walter Szymanski sent an email noting Mr. Fitzgerald pursued a similar audit proposal last year that would have relied on the state auditor general’s office.

The executive told the board in June that the state office would not pick up the matter, Mr. Szymanski wrote. “This item was then revisited [last month], when Mr. Fitzgerald informed the board” he would introduce a motion in April.

Advertise with us

A draft request for proposals will go to the board for final review, Mr. Szymanski added. Mr. Fitzgerald’s motion calls for the request “at the earliest possible date.”

Mr. Fitzgerald is term-limited and completing his third four-year term in the county’s top elected job. While he hasn’t endorsed any of the candidates, he and Mr. Weinstein have been at odds during the race.

Tensions on the retirement board flared last month as County Controller Corey O’Connor pursued a measure to restrict local political contributions from financial firms that invest the county’s pension money. Mr. Weinstein, who has led the field of executive candidates in fundraising and has a penchant for spending big campaign cash on high-end meals and more, argued the proposal was “not worded right” or “in the bounds of the law correctly.”

That led to a heated exchange between him and Mr. Fitzgerald. The measure returned to the board Thursday, and passed in a 3-0 vote, after being referred to a committee. 

Erica Rocchi Brusselars, a candidate for county treasurer, backed Mr. Fitzgerald’s audit request and the ethics effort to restrict donations.

Advertise with us

“In terms of leading a $1 billion pension fund with promises two times that amount — it’s a huge responsibility,” Ms. Rocchi Brusselars said during Thursday’s meeting. “Plan members, residents and businesses of this county need to be assured that those responsible for the plans are always focused on their fiduciary responsibilities.”

Mr. O’Connor, another retirement board member, missed Thursday’s meeting as he and his wife welcomed a newborn, said his alternate, Deputy Controller Amy Weise.

She joined Mr. Fitzgerald, Jennifer Liptak and Sarah Roka to vote for requesting audit proposals. Before abstaining, Mr. DiCristofaro said that “I have no problem with transparency at all” and would favor having a committee review the matter.

Mr. DiCristofaro and Ms. Roka abstained from the vote on Mr. O’Connor’s ethics proposal. Ms. Roka led the committee that was to review the matter, but the panel didn’t have opportunity for due diligence and couldn’t make a recommendation, she said.

Mr. O’Connor has said the restriction on political contributions would be similar to a state law that applies to county and municipal pension plans that receive state assistance. 

Advertise with us

That law “does not apply to Allegheny County,” Ms. Roka said Thursday. “Adopting any of [the proposal’s] provisions without thoroughly evaluating is not something I can support.”

Ms. Weise described the measure as a “straightforward policy” that’s common for pension funds in Pennsylvania. The committee reviewed a draft early this month, she said.

The retirement office has several months to develop administrative procedures to implement the new policy, Ms. Weise said.

Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz