Pittsburgh City Council has given tentative approval to a plan that would revamp the city’s public art commission, changes that would come as discourse around such art — who owns it, who it represents and who gets to create it — continues to fly.

Members unanimously passed three pieces of legislation aimed at overhauling the commission, which is made up of volunteers who weigh in on public art installations and other civic design decisions.

The move comes just weeks after Mayor Ed Gainey’s administration dismissed everyone on the commission, telling them they’d been serving terms that expired months earlier.

The bills focused on updating the way the commission — to be renamed the Art & Civic Design Commission — operates and spends money.

Advertise with us

The changes come amid a continued public reckoning with its art, including art in Pittsburgh. In Schenley Park, a statue of 15th-century explorer and colonizer Christopher Columbus remains standing but covered tightly with plastic.

A judge in October ruled the city has a right to remove the 64-year-old statue. The mayor’s office said at the time only that it was “reviewing the opinion and looking at the next steps moving forward. An Italian-American organization said it would appeal. And in a similar case, a state Commonwealth Court judge ruled this month Philadelphia must remove a box that had covered its Columbus statue, saying the city could add a plaque explaining the historical context.

Also in recent years a statue of Pittsburgh-born songwriter Stephen Foster was decommissioned by Pittsburgh and sent to Los Angeles to stand alongside other decommissioned statues of Confederate generals and others. The statue was mothballed after years of outcry: it depicted a Black slave with a banjo sitting at the feet of the composer.

Mr. Gainey’s administration did not respond to requests for comments about the direction the art commission is headed or the unceremonious dismissal of the commission’s former members.

One piece of legislation would split the commission into two separate but related bodies: One focused on public art and one focused on reviewing design changes or renovations to city property.

Advertise with us

The first goal, Sarah Minnaert, assistant director of public history, art and design, previously said is to help lessen the commission’s load and better focus commissioners’ time by aligning experts with their areas of focus.

A second change would update the city’s Percent for Art Policy. Many cities have similar programs, which set aside a certain percentage of construction or renovation funds to go toward public art at the site. In Pittsburgh, that means the city must set aside 1% of funds for projects that cost $50,000 or more.

Ms. Minnaert said that policy was enacted in 1977 and has not been updated since. It can often fall short, as long-term art installations can cost much more than that 1%. For example, a city project worth $1 million would generate just $10,000 for a public art project.

Limiting public art to the location where work is happening and capping it at 1%, she said, limits opportunities.

“They follow where activity happens in the city,” she said. “If activity is happening on city properties with city funds, that is where public art is being put into the city — it doesn’t look at an equitable distribution across the city.”

Advertise with us

The third piece of legislation would establish a public art trust fund. The trust would be a repository for money given by developers as part of what’s called the Public Art Performance Point Program.

The program was written into the city’s zoning code in 2018 and allows developers to go beyond normal zoning regulations if they incorporate things like public art, energy efficiency and affordable housing into their projects.

The legislation is set for a full council vote Dec. 28.

That vote will come just over a month after previous members received letters informing them they’d been dismissed from the commission — not just dismissed, but had been dismissed months earlier on Jan. 2.

Now-former commissioner Sarika Goulatia posted her letter on social media, noting the commission had been meeting throughout the year — as recently as Nov. 16.

Advertise with us

“Was being critical of city run projects instrumental in this termination?” she questioned in her social media post. “Or is it just what every newly elected mayor does?”

The former iteration of the commission also took issue with the process around the Fern Hollow Bridge rebuild, at one point asking Gov. Tom Wolf to pump the brakes on the design to allow for more input on the aesthetic.

A new slate of commissioners has not been named.

In a discussion prior to the initial vote last week, council President Theresa Kail-Smith said she was pleased the new administration “decided to go in a different direction.” She pointed to a lack of geographic diversity in public art, lamenting the lack of it in the western neighborhoods that she represents.

Councilmember Barbara Warwick said she would like to see more public art geared toward violence prevention and memorializing those lost to violence.

Advertise with us

“Those children, those young people should be memorialized,” she said. “[We should be] treating that as not normal.”

In June 2020, just days after the killing of George Floyd by a then-Minneapolis police officer, an unsanctioned Black Lives Matter mural appeared along the river walk along the south bank of the Allegheny River. The mural has since grown,reports at the time said that then-Mayor Bill Peduto had ordered the city’s Department of Public Works not to remove the mural.