Owners and operators of short-term rental properties voiced support Thursday for regulations proposed by Pittsburgh City Council.
The legislation to regulate these rentals was proposed in mid-April, just days after two teens were killed and many others injured in a shooting that took place in an Airbnb party on the North Side.
To weed out rentals that are owned by out-of-state LLCs or absentee landlords, the legislation wants each property owner to obtain a yearly license to use their building as a short-term rental.
They would then have to keep a log containing the names, addresses and phone numbers of the renters which could be made available for inspection by city code enforcers.
Many of the speakers at Thursday’s public hearing own short-term rentals and some explained how they keep their rentals from being the source of any problems, through things like vetting their guests.
Beechview resident and short-term rental owner Caitlin Jones said her guests are “not partiers” but “future residents of Pittsburgh.”
Read More
Other owners explained various reasons that people rent from them, whether it’s visiting the city for a Steelers game or college graduation or to get the lay of the land before potentially moving here, noting that the local economy benefits from all of these types of visits.
“We know the vast majority of hosts act in good faith to valuable members of our community,” said Chad Wise, a representative from Steel City Short-Term Rental Alliance, a local organization that brings together owners of short-term rentals. “I stand before you all today to unequivocally state that Steel STRA welcomes effective legislation. The key word being ‘effective.’”
Despite the support, various owners noted the same two points of contention in the legislation, which were the duration of the stay and occupancy limit.
Per the legislation, guests would be limited to a stay with a maximum of 15 consecutive days in a 30-day period.
After the public hearing, Councilman Bruce Kraus said he had spoken with an attorney who suggested the council look at a minimum number of days a guest stays rather than a maximum.
That way, council could avoid instances where units might be rented for a single night in order to host a party, similar to how the property involved in the shooting was rented.
The legislation also describes a family unit occupancy limit of not more than three people not related by blood.
Becky Mingo, who clarified that she was speaking to council as a private individual, not a member of the city’s planning commission, suggested that council raise that number to allow more unrelated people to stay together.
She also suggested that the duration of the stay be extended to six months.
The Pennsylvania Restaurant & Lodging Association, which voiced their support for the legislation, suggested that owners also get liability insurance and that the buildings undergo regular safety inspections.
Other speakers were frustrated that the proposed ordinance didn’t deal with the problem of parking, which can come from having many short-term rental properties in one residential area.
There were some in opposition to the legislation, however. Short-term rental owner Cassandra Brandy called it “unnecessary and potentially dangerous.”
“None of the proposed requirements … would have prevented the tragic North [Side] shooting on April 17,” Ms. Brandy said. “Ultimately the host cannot control the actions of guests, and law enforcement needs to step in. We do not need to debate more regulations, we need to enforce the laws and violations we already have.”
As of Thursday afternoon, Pittsburgh Public Safety had “nothing new” to report on the investigation into the shootings, according to spokesperson Cara Cruz. No arrests have been made, and police have not announced that they have any suspects.
In the most recent update on May 10, police released photographs of a man they wanted to identify in connection with the shooting. The man was identified, but Ms. Cruz said she could not provide any information on his identity or involvement.
“I hope that the public does not think that this short-term rental legislation is a knee-jerk reaction to a terrible event that happened on the North [Side],” Councilwoman Erika Strassburger said. “But this has indeed been something that I think every council member has had in their mind for many years now.”
Councilman Bobby Wilson, who represents the district where the shooting occurred, said Thursday’s hearing “opened a new conversation” and that council is “looking at all the options.”
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.