Updated at 3:50 p.m. Monday, Nov. 1.
In the past year, debates over mask mandates, vaccines, remote learning and curricula have dominated school board meetings nationwide. Those same issues are reflected on ballots for school board candidates throughout Allegheny County as Tuesday’s election nears.
MORE ELECTION PREVIEWS:
Read More
▪ Pittsburgh Public Schools board
It’s hard to find campaigns that haven’t mentioned at least one of these topics as candidates in some districts have united as teams with their own names rather than the traditional party labels.
That’s the case in Mt. Lebanon, where a slate called “Friends of Lebo” has rallied around the issue of learning loss, valuable in-person classroom time for students that the group says was lost during the remote instruction of the pandemic.
“We’ve seen over 800 hours of learning loss” from in-class instruction, said Kim Lackner Mauro, one of the five Friends of Lebo. “It’s one of the largest issues.”
Friends of Lebo cited a study from the Horace Mann Educators Corp., which found that over half of K-12 public school educators surveyed said the pandemic resulted in “significant” loss for students, both academically and emotionally. A separate McKinsey report found that after the 2020-2021 academic year, K-12 students were on average five months behind in math and four months behind in reading.
“The residents and the parents of Mt. Lebanon are frustrated, and they’re confused, and they’re ready for some change,” said Pat King, another candidate on the slate. “Over the last year and a half or so, they’ve wanted a certain type of schooling that they didn’t get. They feel they’ve been led down a road, and there’s a lack of trust.”
Friends of Lebo candidate Chris Lust said that if elected, his slate would use Elementary and Secondary School Emergency Relief funds to combat learning loss through 2024. The slate says it would use $2.7 million to fund projects like summer learning, extended days, and after-school programs to close the gap.
While learning loss has been a concern for both liberal and conservative candidates, some slates have chosen to shape their campaigns around topics like diversity and inclusion.
“Diversity in our students and a need for diversity in our education is something I strongly believe in,” said Annamaria Johnson, a candidate of Latina heritage who’s running for school director in Mt. Lebanon with the One Lebo slate.
One Lebo includes Ms. Johnson, Erin Gentzel, Claire Guth and Todd Ellwein.
On their campaign site, Ms. Johnson said that creating a Diversity, Equity and Inclusion program for students and staff was of great importance to her.
“My daughter is a senior, she’s never had a teacher of color,” Ms. Johnson added. “When I went to college that was the first time I ever had a teacher of color. That is one of the reasons that I’m running, is to make sure that we have representation for all our students. Our community is changing, it is becoming a more progressive community, and it’s also becoming a more diverse community, and we need to make sure that all students are included in the decisions that we’re making.”
In the Hampton Township School District, a group calling itself “The Four” is heavily in support of parent choice. For The Four — comprised of parents Rachael Mazzoni, Jeremiah Lambo, John Ontko, and Sean Grimm — this means parents would get to choose whether their children wear masks and study certain social topics in class.
While eight other candidates are on the ballot for seats in Hampton, The Four are running as write-ins.
On The Four’s website, the candidates say they support “traditional learning,” which they say would reduce social and moral topics from the curriculum and instead focus on reading, writing, and arithmetic. On the group’s Facebook page, one post reads “Education — not indoctrination.”
While masks in all Pennsylvania K-12 schools have been mandated by Gov. Tom Wolf, The Four pushed back against regulations on their Facebook page.
“As we know, our current school board blindly follows these government officials who we did not elect in Hampton,” a post said. “The Four will make decisions based on what’s good for Hampton — not politics. We are running as parents.”
In other district races, candidates have latched on to issues that have caught on nationally.
Greg Dolan, who is running for a seat in Fox Chapel Area, appeared on “Fox and Friends” in July and said he was running to fight the teaching of critical race theory in the district.
He said in an interview Friday that CRT is a “harmful ideology” that pits student against student, teachers against students and teachers against teachers, based purely on their looks. Mr. Dolan said he believes Fox Chapel students deserve an excellent education, free from divisive ideologies.
Mr. Dolan, who teaches U.S. history at Aquinas Academy in Hampton and volunteers on Fox Chapel’s Resources Planning Committee, wrote on his website that he believes there should be no mandatory mask rules for children in the 2020-21 school year, and pledged to “stop critical race theory indoctrination.”
Additionally, Mr. Dolan pledged on his website to reduce taxes and place emphasis on fiscal responsibility.
During an Oct. 11 Fox Chapel school board meeting, Mr. Dolan began to speak about a consultant that the district hired to teach race, racism and inclusivity with administrators in the district when the board told Mr. Dolan that the consultant was not on the agenda, and to refrain from speaking about the topic.
As Mr. Dolan continued, there was one loud “boo” from the audience, and the school board unanimously voted to temporarily adjourn.
Mr. Dolan posted on Facebook that he had received the endorsement of Terry Wirginis, who served on Fox Chapel’s school board from 2011-2019, and was president for four of those years.
“Thankfully, there is a candidate for school board who wants to heal and not divide, who wants to hear from the community, and who would be an independent voice for those ignored by the current school directors,” Mr. Wirginis wrote in the letter that Mr. Dolan shared on Facebook. “That candidate is Greg Dolan.”
Mr. Dolan is running for the school board’s region 2, which includes Indiana Township and districts 2, 4 and 5 in Fox Chapel borough. He will be facing Ariel Zych.
Ms. Zych on her campaign website advocated for changes in student assessment beyond standardized testing, which she said can be unfair to some students.
“Particularly after the incredible learning loss and transition that our students have been through since 2020, benchmarking students using outdated testing is a waste of resources,” she writes. “We have an opportunity to lead with authentic assessments that invite students to demonstrate proficiency through real world tasks, oral and written arguments, project based learning, and self-directed inquiry.”
She also calls for overhauling the ways the district provides data in a variety of areas, saying it could be more transparent.
On fiscal matters she says ’Unlike my opponent, I will never advocate that we spend down our reserve fund to address projected deficits, because I know that for some districts, that has spelled financial disaster, grand jury investigations, and ultimately state control.”
She also wrote that “I have spoken with many parents in the district who feel like their voices are not heard, and their perspectives are not fairly considered. We must make community voice a permanent part of our school district proceedings.”
Regarding CRT: “My opponent is trying to actively divide us, neighbor from neighbor, by disingenuously asserting that racism, classism, and sexism simply don’t exist here, and by concocting a crusade on Critical Race Theory to fuel his personal political campaign. He is choosing to silence the experiences of families who have felt excluded, to disparage our well-intentioned schools, and to reject outright the worthy goal of working for every child to feel included (inclusion), valued for who they are (diversity), and treated fairly (equity).
“This is harmful, and has no place on our school board.”
Finally, Ms. Zych writes, “I know that we can maintain great, inclusive public schools without bringing Critical Race Theory, the 1619 Project, or the 1776 Project into the mix; we have it within our community to build an inclusive Fox Chapel Area School District. Working together, we can build an FCASD for All.”
Post-Gazette staff writer Kellen Stepler contributed.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.