A judge’s imminent decision on whether Allegheny County is permitted to tally ballots that were submitted on time but without a printed date could decide a state Senate race.

In a hearing before Common Pleas Senior Judge Joseph James on Tuesday, a lawyer for Nicole Ziccarelli — a GOP candidate seeking to unseat Sen. Jim Brewster in the 45th District — argued that 2,349 ballots should be tossed out because the election code makes it clear that mail-in ballots are required to have a written date on the outer envelope.

The ballots in question are otherwise eligible, and were scanned into the county’s system on time — prompting its board of elections to greenlight their counting. Ms. Ziccarelli is challenging that decision, and Judge James said he expects to rule on the matter by Wednesday.

The Republican is down by 30 votes in her race against Mr. Brewster, D-McKeesport.

Advertise with us

In the portion of the district that’s in Allegheny County, Mr. Brewster’s 6,130-vote lead has been bolstered by his winning of mail-in ballots — like the ones in dispute — by a near 2.5-to-1 margin. The Westmoreland County segment that went to Ms. Ziccarelli by 6,100 votes hasn’t yet uploaded its counting of eligible provisional ballots. There are more than 3,600 across all of Westmoreland that continue to be reviewed, according to Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV.

Allegheny County’s lawyer, Virginia Scott, said the court should seek to protect the right to vote in its interpretation of the election code, and that because no fraud or malfeasance is alleged, the law should be read to ensure voter enfranchisement, not disenfranchisement.

“It is not required that a ballot be filled out perfectly,” Ms. Scott said. “It’s required that a ballot be filled out sufficiently, and that's what these ballots are.”

Matt Haverstick, representing Ms. Ziccarelli, said voters still have to follow rules — they can’t vote twice, for example — and that the rules here, as “clearly intended” by the Legislature, were that mail-in voters “shall” fill out, date and sign the outer declaration. The word “shall,” he argued, was intended to be mandatory.

Countering that the election code was frontloaded with requirements to establish a voter’s qualifications, Ms. Scott alleged that Ms. Ziccarelli is trying to disenfranchise voters because of a technical mistake — which the code “does not tolerate.”

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.