As the COVID-19 pandemic grows, safety questions surround Pennsylvania's April 28 primary. For the Post-Gazette's Politically Inclined podcast, Julian Routh and Daniel Moore spoke with Chris Deluzio, the policy director for Pitt’s Institute for Cyber Law, Policy, and Security. Should Pennsylvania delay its primary election? Can it do so legally?

This interview was recorded March 19, 2020. It has been edited for length and clarity.

Download and subscribe to Politically Inclined for free on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts and Spotify.

____

Advertise with us

Julian Routh: I'm Julian Routh from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, and this is Politically Inclined. As the number of confirmed cases of coronavirus increases by the day — by the hour, actually, in Pennsylvania — the calendar gets closer and closer to April 28. That is, of course, the date of the Pennsylvania primary election. And although the Democratic presidential race is nearly settled, and in the hands of former Vice President Joe Biden, there are dozens, dozens of contested races here in Allegheny County and hundreds across Pennsylvania. But what would happen if we get to April 28 and people are cautioned to stay away from the polls? What would happen if on the day of these important contests poll workers took it upon themselves to look out for their own health? Our guest this week has been thinking about this, particularly about what would happen if Pennsylvania tried to suspend or postpone its primary election. I'm talking, of course, about Chris Deluzio. He's an election security expert and policy director of the University of Pittsburgh’s Institute for Cyber Law, Policy and Security, and he's been sounding the alarm about what state law says, or more importantly, doesn't say about postponing elections. In fact, Pennsylvania's election code says, quote, "less than you would hope" about suspending a contest, he told me this week. Now we've got him here on Politically Inclined. Chris, welcome to the podcast.

Chris Deluzio: Julian, thanks for having me. I'm looking forward to the chat today.

Julian Routh: Thank you. And as always, Daniel Moore, the Post-Gazette's Washington, D.C., bureau chief. Daniel, how's it going, man?

Daniel Moore: Well, I'm hanging in there like everyone else in the country.

Julian Routh: So just for the record, we're here remotely. We're all working from home. That's why we're all talking on the phone and the audio quality might be a little bit different, but desperate times call for desperate measures, and we're here to do it. Chris, Gov. Tom Wolf has floated the possibility of postponing the April 28 primary, but you've said that, at least if done now, that could get a little bit messy. Why do you say that?

Advertise with us

Chris Deluzio: Well, unfortunately, we don't have a clear provision in our election code here in Pennsylvania that provides for a suspension or postponement of our primary election. There's no provision that says this is how you do it, and this is who does it. Rather what we've had developed here in Pennsylvania is some case law where a Court of Common Pleas, so a county court, really deals with a lawsuit, where there's something affecting voting. An example I usually give is the flooding that we saw in Washington County in the ‘80s. This was the case that worked its way through the courts where they recognized: Hey, we can postpone or suspend voting in that situation.

But that's a far cry from we have now, where we're facing a global public health pandemic. And we're looking at a statewide postponement. So what I think we need to do is to have action from the General Assembly to make clear who has the power to move this date and in fact, perhaps the General Assembly itself sets a different date. But either way, I think voters deserve to have a clear answer about who has authority, who else might be a stakeholder involved in deciding whether there's a postponement of April 28 and what the bases are for doing so — and we don't have that now.

Julian Routh: Now, we're recording this on Thursday (March 19). By the time this podcast goes live, you could very well see more big names in Harrisburg advocating for pushing this election back. You could see some legislation being introduced in the capital as the number of cases of coronavirus rises. Without revising the election code or providing this clarity you're calling for, how would this process play out right now?

Chris Deluzio: Well, it's not perfectly clear and maybe that's the point. But if I read the tea leaves, I think what would happen, absent some action from the General Assembly, would be a lawsuit in Court of Common Pleas, or perhaps even ending up in the commonwealth court, looking to suspend or postpone the April 28 primary election due to the coronavirus pandemic. How that would play out would entirely depend on the judges and the case, and I frankly can't point you to any clear set of factors or rules that will dictate an outcome in that litigation.

I think that, for me, reinforces why Pennsylvania voters and the public in general deserve some clarity from Harrisburg, and deserve decisive and clear action. Particularly since we have more than a month until we're set to vote, we have time to do things properly and give voters the confidence that if things are changing, they're changing for fair and clear reasons, and they'll know exactly what will come in terms of a later date if that's where we land.

Advertise with us

Daniel Moore: Chris, are you concerned about the precedent that moving in elections would set? I mean, we clearly are in an unprecedented time, and there are public safety and health concerns with holding elections. So why shouldn't the state right now say, "The world isn't gonna look that much safer by April 28, let's just postpone this right now, like other states have done."

Chris Deluzio: Well, I guess I would draw a distinction, which I think is really important to draw between our nominating contests, which are our primaries in April, and the general election. I think states oftentimes move when their primary elections are across presidential cycles, for instance, over years, and so those days sometimes shift. And, I think, unlike November, where we're actually electing people to office to include the president and every member of the House of Representatives and many senators, there's a constitutional imperative that we need to hold a November election.

In my mind, there should be no reason whatsoever to entertain any sort of postponement of moving November's election. But I do think the primary is different and I'm not taking the position that we should move it or not. What I'm simply saying is, I know the governor and many election officials want to move the primary in April, and if they're going to do that, I think we as Pennsylvanians deserve a clear reason for doing so grounded against something that the General Assembly provided so that there's a statutory basis to move the primary — and that we don't have now.

Julian Routh: Now I know you're not taking a position on whether or not they should. Regardless, it's still tough to get things done in Harrisburg. It's tough to get things done quickly. And if this has to come down to the General Assembly agreeing on some legislation to revise the code, there's going to have to be some bipartisan consensus. Now at the same time, you saw recently there was some partisanship with the special election this past week, and they decided not to move them. I wonder, how much do you foresee partisanship playing a role in the decision to move this primary?

Chris Deluzio: Well, I wish I could say I don't foresee any role partisanship might play here, but I think we all know that's not true of Harrisburg, unfortunately. I would hope in the midst of a frankly global crisis that our leaders, who have all taken over to the commonwealth and to this country, will do what's right and put the voters and our health and our democracy first. I can't imagine a more pressing issue for them to confront right now, along with all the economic and health consequences of this crisis. So I really hope that our legislators are able to come together and figure this out so that we can protect our democracy and protect our public health. And to let partisan petty squabbling get in the way of that would be a disservice to all of us.

Advertise with us

Julian Routh: One of the things that there is no petty squabbling over right now is that people seem to universally agree mail-in balloting is a good option; that people should apply for a mail-in ballot if they're concerned about potentially not being able to go to the polls on April 28, out of fear for their safety. I wonder, why is having this option of mail-in balloting important? And would you give the same advice to people while this process plays out?

Chris Deluzio: I would absolutely urge Pennsylvania voters who are able to vote by mail to request their mail-in ballot now. We forget that for many years, we didn't have that option. In Pennsylvania, you had to have an excuse to vote absentee. Well, this April is the first election where, statewide, we can do no excuse mail-in balloting.

So I really urge voters to request those ballots for their own health but also the health of poll workers and for our vulnerable citizens who might need to go to the polls because they require an accessible voting option, for instance. So, this is not a perfect solution for every voter. Again, those who require accessible voting options like ballot marking devices will need to be able to vote in person if they're able.

I think doing this can help alleviate pressure on polling places and poll workers, and is something that we ought to be taking advantage of now — and a benefit is it doesn't require any change from Harrisburg. It's already a law in the state that you can request a mail-in ballot without an excuse and we have several weeks still to request those mail-in ballots before the April 28 election, assuming it happens as planned.

Daniel Moore: This is obviously a state issue, but looking at the issue nationally, the response from various states has been so fragmented and unpredictable. I'm wondering to what extent you think state officials should be coordinating among themselves or with federal officials to come up with some kind of unified national approach here so that voters know what to expect come their election day.

Advertise with us

Chris Deluzio: It's a great question. I point to an example out of Washington just this week. Senators [Ron] Wyden and [Amy] Klobuchar introduced a bill to make several key changes to how we execute the November election to include a dramatic expansion of vote-by-mail resources to election officials in the states. Some procedures around early voting to make sure that's an option across the country. I think we have to be considering those options and more, because there's a strong likelihood that this may continue, or at least some version of what's happening right now around this public health crisis. But we're still trying to avoid congregating in large groups, where seniors and other vulnerable populations, in particular who happened to staff on polling places, aren't able to do that.

So we should be taking every action we can now, of course here in Pennsylvania, but also across the country, so that we can make November's election happen and still be able to give up folks ways to vote without sacrificing their health and the health of their neighbors. So I think the senators' proposal is a very good one — and I think one that recognizes this is not just a county or state problem. It's a national problem.

Julian Routh: So you lay out a very compelling case for why the stakeholders should act to revise the code, but from what you know about the forces at play here — and obviously people are looking for some pragmatism among their officials here — how do you actually foresee this playing out over the next couple of weeks and see this ending up on April 28 or afterward?

Chris Deluzio: It's really tough to predict, but if listened to what the governor has been saying, and I listened to what many of the county election officials have now said about their view that they don't think they can really administer an election on April 28, I'm hopeful that we'll get some action from the General Assembly to address that. So whether that means there's simply a move of this date — this day being as April's primary date — or something that will exist in the election code beyond this year to govern emergency situation affecting elections in particular primary elections. I'm hopeful something will happen. I just look at the the facts that are in front of us now, which seem to be evolving by the minute, and frankly, can't square those facts with inaction from Harrisburg and so I'm hopeful they'll do something.

Julian Routh: There's all these moving parts here and I know that in the past, you've testified about election security in front of various governmental bodies, including, I think you're in Allegheny County with the board of elections. Now, you've studied the selection of new voting systems in particular, and I had one election official tell me this week that they were worrying about these new systems and preparing voters and poll workers to use them, before coronavirus popped up. Now these worries are even more amplified with these new systems and being expected to use them, but do you share these concerns from all you've studied?

Advertise with us

Chris Deluzio: I certainly do, and I'll say it's an election administration challenge to roll out new voting machines. I applaud much of what's been done in Allegheny County and in lots of counties in Pennsylvania to prepare for new machines, but when you layer in this crisis, Allegheny County is a good example. The county postponed poll worker training, I believe, late last week and that's important for a bunch of reasons. One, if poll workers are trained and able to show up, that's an obvious issue with putting polling places up and running, but even if they are able to show up but aren't adequately trained to deal with new voting machines, that's a recipe for quite a bit of long lines, machines not being up properly — all things that can affect turnout and really suppressed folks votes. So these are not just health-related issues. There are collateral consequences that will affect the administration of our election and the staffing of polling places, all of which can really undermine the right to vote if we aren't smart about it and smart about how to confront it while we have time.

Julian Routh: I want to end this with a message to our listeners who are sitting at home right now, hopefully, worried about their safety and worried about the election coming up. What would you urge people to do? How can they take action?

Chris Deluzio: Specifically around the election I would urge Pennsylvania residents to request a mail ballot and do what they can to protect their right to vote without having to go to the polling places. And I think more broadly — and it's not original advice coming from me — but to do everything I can to heed the public health orders that we're hearing from cities and counties in the state, and to help out neighbors and family as best they can who might need assistance and might have a hard time getting access to food or medical care through all of this. I think we can't do enough to help each other and those around us.

Julian Routh: Chris, our time is up and I just wanted to thank you for for coming on the show in this very hectic time. We really appreciate it.

Chris Deluzio: Thanks for having me on guys, it was a treat. I really, really appreciate it.

Julian Routh: There you have it. You've been listening to Politically Inclined, a podcast by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. I'm Julian Routh. As always, he's Daniel Moore in Washington, D.C. We'll see you soon for another episode. Please stay safe and informed and to do so you can read the Post-Gazette's coronavirus coverage by subscribing at post-gazette.com. Thank you for listening.