In the wake of voter approval Tuesday of a Pittsburgh property tax add-on to improve parks, city officials on Wednesday weighed how and when the controversial ballot referendum will be implemented, especially in light of sharp neighborhood-by-neighborhood differences in opinion about the new levy.

Councilman Anthony Coghill — who opposed the tax, and saw much of his South Hills district vote solidly against it — nonetheless vowed Wednesday to “make sure that it's equitable and that my parks get at least their 1/9” share. There are nine council districts.

“I want to do anything and everything I can to direct that money equally into the districts.”

The half-mill tax — which adds $50 to the owner’s tax bill for every $100,000 in property value — aims to raise $10 million a year to support improvements and maintenance in parks, and city recreational programs.  In an as-yet-unofficial count, it passed by 2,399 votes out of 65,129 cast. That’s a margin of victory of around 3.7 percentage points.

Advertise with us

The ballot referendum won big majorities — polling above 70% — in the wards anchored by the Hill District and Oakland. It didn't beat 35%, though, in the wards including Brookline, Beechview, Carrick, Sheraden, Overbrook and Hays.

In the North Side, results ranged widely by ward, with the tax winning 63% in the ward anchored by Allegheny Center, but just 42% in the ward including Troy Hill.

Much of the South Side and the nearby Hilltop neighborhoods were almost evenly split on the issue.

Voting districts within wards were “wildly different,” noted Council President Bruce Kraus, of the South Side Flats. “People living side by side had completely polarized views of it.”

He must now preside over a City Council process in relation to the tax that could be as contentious as the referendum itself. Four of the nine council members (including outgoing Councilwoman Darlene Harris) were vocal opponents of the tax.

Advertise with us

Council is charged with passing authorizing legislation to implement the tax, creating a trust fund to hold its receipts, and authorizing any contract the city would enter into with an outside entity, likely to be the Pittsburgh Parks Conservancy.

“I think that [council’s] first order of business should be to create a park and name it after Lisa Middleman,” joked city Controller Michael Lamb, noting that the tax did well in the same districts in which the unsuccessful independent challenger to Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. rolled up big margins. “If you didn’t have her on the ballot yesterday, this doesn’t pass,” he said theorizing that she drew African American voters who also responded to the conservancy’s pledge to spend money in disadvantaged districts.

“Council has got a lot of work to do on this,” Mr. Lamb said. “Almost a majority of council was opposed to this. So they’ll have to work through this in a way that follows the intent of the question” that voters narrowly approved.

Mr. Lamb said he does not believe council could simply decline to implement the will of the majority of voters. Council could, however, insist that the conservancy fulfill its pledge to privately raise matching funds before disbursing any of the tax proceeds.

He added that “there’s a whole lot of room for [council] to do a lot of things with respect to their neighborhood interests,” by insisting on a distribution of the funds that is fair, or at least that matches the pro-tax side’s promises to start in underserved communities.

Advertise with us

While Mr. Coghill said he’d insist that the South Hills get its share, Councilwoman Erika Strassburger said that the big parks of the East End “are doing OK” and “don’t need funding.” Schenley, Frick, Riverview, Highland and Emerald View parks get annual infusions from the Allegheny County Regional Asset District 1% sales tax.

“It's not the RAD parks that everyone thinks about. It's the little neighborhood parks that will get the love” from the tax, said Timothy McNulty, spokesman for Mayor Bill Peduto, who supported the tax. “It's about funding neighborhood parks that have been neglected for decades.”

Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542