Two candidates for a western Allegheny County district judge seat are coming down the home stretch with similar bases of support but very different viewpoints on the experience that qualifies one to sit on the bench.

Michelle Santicola and Max Feldman are lawyers, Moon residents and registered Democrats. In a May primary in which candidates can file with both major parties, Ms. Santicola won the Democratic nod and Mr. Feldman the Republican, setting up their general election face-off Tuesday.

Ms. Santicola, 49, emphasizes the breadth of her experience, including nine years as a prosecutor with the state attorney general, and as a hearing examiner for the Liquor Control Board.

“So for four years, I sat at a judge’s bench and took testimony from witnesses, made rulings on evidence” in liquor license matters, she said in an October interview. “These are things [Mr. Feldman has] never done.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Feldman, 56, counters with his depth of immersion in the world of magistrate’s court, where he has represented many clients in small claims, non-criminal matters and preliminary hearings. He said he’s done “many, many summary cases, representing folks on speeding tickets and different summaries. ... That’s really the heart of what is done at the magistrate’s office.”

Mary Murray held the district judge seat that serves Coraopolis, Crescent, Neville and Moon for 14 years, until she ascended to the state Superior Court last year.

In the primaries, Ms. Santicola got a total of 1,754 votes to Mr. Feldman’s 1,538, with 971 going to attorney Corrie Woods.

Mr. Woods has endorsed Ms. Santicola, saying she has shown “the class, grace, and integrity to help us fix our broken politics.”

Mr. Feldman said his focus on “regular folks” contrasts with Ms. Santicola’s campaign, which included a fundraiser at the Montour Heights Country Club.

Advertise with us

“I haven't been able to do that,” he said of the fundraiser.

His fundraising drew criticism when a Sept. 19 email surfaced in which he appeared to personally solicit contributions — something judicial candidates are not allowed to do under state law. He acknowledged that the email was a mistake.

The email does not appear to have measurably affected fundraising in the race.

From June 10 through Oct. 21, Mr. Feldman’s campaign raised $13,219 — of which he personally contributed $11,194. The campaign also spent $11,194, finishing the period with $2,175 in the bank.

In the same period, Ms. Santicola’s campaign raised $17,580 — all from donors — and spent $14,081. Her campaign had $14,786 in the bank.

Advertise with us

“I have a lot of good friends who really believe in me and believe that I’m the right person for this job,” Ms. Santicola said.

Her campaign also reported a $10,000 debt to her husband, attorney Michael Santicola.

Michelle Santicola touted her community work as a member of the Moon Board of Supervisors and the Coraopolis Shade Tree Commission, and as a volunteer with food banks.

“I challenge anyone to match my record on community involvement,” she said.

Mr. Feldman countered that he has “worked closely with members of our community throughout 27 years of law practice at the same office in Coraopolis” and that has “made me very familiar with the many ways people try to avoid answering for their choices.”

Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542