An email soliciting contributions to a candidate for district judge serving the Moon-Coraopolis area has added heat to an already-contentious race between two lawyers.
A Sept. 19 email from a paralegal working for Republican nominee Max Feldman, 56, included this sentence: "I also welcome fund donations to support my campaign."
Signed, "Best regards, Max," it appears to be at odds with state law that says judicial candidates aren't allowed to "personally solicit or accept campaign contributions other than through a campaign committee."
“I regret it. It was a mistake. This is my first campaign. That's not an excuse. ... I own this,” Mr. Feldman said in an interview Tuesday.
His rival, Democratic nominee Michelle Santicola, argued that the the “mistake” was telling, coming from a candidate who had criticized her level of experience.
“You want to enforce the rules, you need to know the rules,” said Ms. Santicola, 49. “He's in the business of attacking me on a lot of issues. ... What I do is I learn the rules, I know the rules and I follow the rules."
Read More
The two are competing in the Nov. 5 election for the job held for 14 years by Mary P. Murray, who took a seat on the Superior Court last year. Both contenders are registered Democrats who cross-filed in the primary, winning respective party nods.
Mr. Feldman, an attorney in general practice for three decades, has said that his extensive experience representing “regular folks” in landlord-tenant cases, summary and traffic offenses, preliminary hearings and small civil claims makes him the best choice.
"My office is right down the street from the magistrate's office. I go to magistrate's offices all the time on these kinds of matters," he said Tuesday. Of Ms. Santicola, he said, "I've never seen her in court.”
"I am the only candidate in the race who has been on both sides" of cases, countered Ms. Santicola. "I've been a prosecutor [with the Pennsylvania attorney general's office]. I have jury trial experience in several counties. ... I did appellate cases. ... I also was a hearing examiner for the liquor control board."
She said she also volunteered in the narrowly unsuccessful 2017 state Supreme Court campaign of Dwayne Woodruff, who remains on the Court of Common Pleas. One of her roles was to accompany the candidate, she said, so that if the topic of campaign funding came up, she could step in.
That’s because state law bars judicial candidates from personally asking for, or receiving, campaign funds.
"They can't ask for anything, either monetary contributions or in-kind contributions," said Chester Corse, an attorney at Williamson, Friedberg & Jones, based in Pottsville, who handles election law cases and has written extensively about judicial conduct. Why not? To avoid the appearance, he said, that "the judge is being bribed" with campaign contributions.
The judge or judicial candidate has to have someone else handle the nitty gritty of fundraising, he said. He said that campaign code violations can be reported to the state Court of Judicial Discipline, and that body has the power to issue fines and penalties, and, for sitting judges, to suspend or remove them from the bench.
“You can say, 'promote my campaign,' but the word donate or contribution cannot come out of the mouth of a candidate for judicial office," said Micah C.T. Sims, executive director of the watchdog group Common Cause Pennsylvania. Those words should also "never come out of [the judicial candidate’s] keyboard, or text message.”
Mr. Feldman said he's aware of the rule and its purpose, and doesn't think the Sept. 19 email "crosses the line, but I certainly understand the issue with it.
"The purpose of it wasn't really fundraising," he said, noting that it first asks for volunteers. "I made a mistake. We're not perfect. Nobody is."
It is as-yet unclear whether the email resulted in contributions. Campaigns don't have to disclose summer and fall fundraising until Oct. 25.
Through June 10 — the last period for which campaign fundraising totals are public — Mr. Feldman's campaign had $12,340 in its account, after receiving $5,545 in contributions during the five weeks prior to that. Of that total, though, $5,394 was donated to the campaign by Mr. Feldman himself.
Ms. Santicola's campaign, at the same point, had $11,288 in its account. Her campaign had raised, over the five weeks prior, $2,350, from five donors.
Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.