Two Allegheny County Council members introduced legislation to ban sexual orientation and gender conversion therapy for minors Tuesday, generating heated public comment, with speakers on both sides of the ordinance.

The legislation was referred to council’s Health and Human Services Committee after introduction by Council President John DeFazio, D-Shaler, and Councilman Paul Klein, D-Point Breeze.

"This proposed ordinance is intended to ban therapeutically discredited practices that not only have proven to be ineffective but are clearly deemed harmful and in many respects perpetuate the marginalization of LGBTQIA community in our society," Mr. Klein said in introducing the ordinance.

Conversion therapy is a practice that attempts to change a person's sexual or gender identity using psychological or spiritual interventions.

Advertise with us

"Instead of trying to convert or change people into who we might want them to be, why can't we just take steps toward accepting and maybe loving them for who they are?" Mr. Klein said.

The ordinance would amend the county’s Health and Sanitation Code to prohibit “practices by mental health professionals to convert [a minor] individual’s sexual orientation or gender identity or expression," and defines a mental health professional broadly as anyone who provides "mental health services.”

Councilwoman Sue Means, R-Bethel Park, spoke against the ordinance. "We are taking away children's rights to seek help, and we are interfering in parental rights," she said.

During council’s public comment period, the first speaker, Cullen Boyer, of Penn Hills, spoke in favor of the ban.

"I am bisexual. I was raised in a very Christian household and was told my entire life that anything other than being straight was sinful," he said.

Advertise with us

"Fortunately, my parents never found out while I was a minor. Many children have to go through this disgusting, evil abuse."

The majority of the other speakers spoke against the ban, arguing the ordinance is overly broad and would ban religious counseling.

"As the bill reads, [mental health professionals] would include pastors, religious ministers. It would prevent me from practicing historical Christianity," said the Rev. Richard Lang, of Monroeville's Grace Reformed Presbyterian Church.

"If this bill becomes law, I will be made to act in criminal behavior. I will be forced to violate this law."

Curtis Schube, legal counsel with the Harrisburg-based Pennsylvania Family Institute, said the ban would be unconstitutional, violating provisions of a 2018 U.S. Supreme Court decision.

Advertise with us

"It's contrary to freedom to prevent a minor from getting care that he or she wants," said Mr. Schube.

Following the meeting, several council members said they wanted to hold public hearings on the ordinance.

"This needs to be vetted before the public," said Councilman Patrick Catena, D-Carnegie.

"I'm undecided at this point. This is a tough issue and I don't think it should be rushed," said Councilman Nick Futules, D-Oakmont.

Other members were more firmly planted.

Advertise with us

Denise Ranalli-Russell, D-Brighton Heights, said, "I don't feel it's taking away parental rights," and said Mr. Boyer's story had her "almost in tears."

Sam Demarco, an at-large Republican, said, "I'm opposed on the basis that I believe it denies children their rights, their ability to seek treatment they want."

Mr. Catena, Ms. Ranalli-Russell, and council members Anita Prizio, D-O’Hara, and Dewitt Walton, D-Hill District, have signed on as co-sponsors.

Mr. DeFazio’s challenger in the Democratic primary in May, Bethany Hallam, said at the meeting that she had called on Mr. DeFazio to introduce this legislation and received the endorsement of the Steel City Stonewall Democrats, the party’s LGBT political advocacy group.

"You can have a voice even as a candidate," she said.

Advertise with us

Mr. DeFazio acknowledged the call from Ms. Hallam but said he was responding to a call from the Stonewall Democrats to introduce such legislation.

"We're not prejudiced. We're one of the two counties in the whole state that have passed legislation to prohibit discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity. We're ahead of the curve," said Mr. DeFazio.

"I'm worried about the reporting mechanism, which we need to see, and enforcement mechanisms,” said Ms. Hallam. “We need to find a way to make this a criminal violation, to make sure it's not just lip service.”

Mr. DeFazio said enforcement mechanisms for the bill would be discussed during public hearings or committee meetings.

Christopher Huffaker: chuffaker@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1724, or @huffakingit.