The Congressional District map that state Republican leaders produced late last week doesn’t have districts that resemble Rorschach tests. It doesn’t fracture municipalities like plates dropped on a hardwood floor. But as a look at its potential impact on the hotly contested 18th Congressional District shows, that doesn’t make the picture prettier for Democrats.

While Gov. Tom Wolf seems certain to reject or alter the GOP proposal, observers say it proves that it takes more than an artful map to change the political landscape.

“They made it as tough as it was in the current map,” said Mike Mikus, a Democratic strategist. “You can move a line a couple miles and change everything,”

The GOP-proposed map, drawn by party leaders without being passed by the Legislature, was prompted by a state Supreme Court ruling that congressional districts were unconstitutionally drawn for partisan advantage. The court ordered the Legislature and Mr. Wolf to produce a map whose districts were “compact and contiguous” and “which do not divide any county [or local municipality] except where necessary” to maintain population balance. If elected officials fail to devise a suitable map, the court has pledged to draw a map of its own.

Advertise with us

Republicans redrew eastern Pennsylvania’s crazy-quilt 7th District, whose shape was likened to “Goofy kicking Donald Duck.” Also rehabilitated is Western Pennsylvania’s 12th District, which looks a bit like God and Adam touching fingers on the Sistine Chapel’s ceiling.

Yet critics aren’t satisfied.

The current congressional map, established in 2011. (Philadelphia Inquirer)

“A pretty map is not necessarily a fair map,” said Carol Kuniholm, election reform director for the League of Women Voters, which filed the suit leading to the redrawn maps. “You can draw a very gerrymandered map that looks nicer than what was done in the past.”

Republicans reject such criticism.

"It is easy to zoom in on an individual line and nitpick,” said Neal Lesher, spokesman for House Speaker Mike Turzai, R-Bradford Woods. “You have to view the map as a whole against the criteria that the court set: compactness, contiguity and reducing splits.”

Advertise with us

Asked Monday about criticism from Democrats and others who think the map he proposed favors Republicans just as much as the current map, Mr. Turzai himself said, "I think they're wrong." He pointed out that President Trump won in Pennsylvania.

In the 18th District, Republicans proposed meeting the court’s criteria by transferring Pittsburgh’s southern suburbs to the city-centric 14th District, while absorbing northern Westmoreland County and portions of Greene and Washington counties.

Those lines would exclude Mt. Lebanon resident Conor Lamb, the Democrat hoping to hold the seat, if he runs for a full term in November. (Mr. Lamb is facing Republican Rick Saccone in a special election March 13 to hold the seat through 2018. The boundaries in that race will remain as they are.) Mr. Lamb doesn’t have to live in the district to run in it, but for Democrats, the larger problem may be that Mr. Lamb’s neighbors could no longer vote for him.

Mr. Mikus said Democratic hopes rely on college-educated and other Democratic-friendly suburbanites who feel little affinity for President Donald Trump — or Mr. Saccone, who professes to be just like the president.

“So you get rid of places like Mt. Lebanon and add [more conservative] Washington and Greene, which makes it a tougher climb,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mike Johnson, who does political data analysis for the AFL-CIO, calculates that the GOP-configured 18th would give Republicans an additional 5-point edge. That’s in a district that the past two Republican presidential nominees won by roughly 20 points, and that former Congressman Tim Murphy ruled with only token challengers for the better part of two decades before stepping down last fall amid scandal.

“Clearly they tried to make the maps look a little nicer,” said Mr. Johnson. But they could afford to, he said, because Democrats congregate in more densely populated areas such as Pittsburgh and its immediate surroundings.

“Gerrymandering involves trying to pack voters into a district,” Mr. Johnson said. “But if Democrats pack themselves, they’ll probably have less representation than their numbers suggest they should.”

He added, “The more that happens, the less crazy you have to draw the lines.”

Ms. Kuniholm and others say legislators could draw more competitive districts if they wanted to. The 3rd District north of Pittsburgh could be more competitive by centering more closely on Erie, for example.

Advertise with us

But Democrats may want to tamp down their expectations no matter who draws the map, said David Wasserman, who handicaps House races for the Cook Political Report.

“I don’t think Republicans can expect to go on holding 13 seats” of the state’s 18, he said. But “I don’t think Democrats should expect a 9-9 map, either.” Because of Democratic clustering, he said, “The results will probably end up somewhere in between.”

Liz Navratil contributed. Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.