Last January, Pennsylvania Sen. Bob Casey found himself in an unlikely position for an anti-abortion Democrat: When Republicans tried to prevent Planned Parenthood from receiving federal money -- even for non-abortion services -- Mr. Casey rallied to the provider’s cause.

“He’s on the right side of that fight,” a spokeswoman for the organization said at the time.

This January, however, has cast Mr. Casey in a less surprising role: He voted Monday with just two other Senate Democrats to ban abortions after the 20th week of fetal development. And while the legislation’s failure was certain, the effect of Mr. Casey’s vote on his re-election this year was less clear.

Mr. Casey’s vote “definitely affects the political choices we advocate for at New Voices for Reproductive Justice,” said Shenay Jeffrey, a board member for the local advocacy group.

Advertise with us

Senate Bill 2311 would criminalize the actions of doctors who perform abortions after the 20th week of fetal development, except in cases of rape or incest, or when the pregnant woman’s life was at risk. Pennsylvania’s Republican senator, Pat Toomey, supported the bill, to no one’s surprise.

Mr. Casey's office issued a statement Monday asserting that, while he would vote in favor of the bill, he wouls "also continue to fight extreme Republicans' attempts to undermine women's health care, such as access to contraception." The office also touted Mr. Casey’s support for Medicaid, whose beneficiaries include working poor mothers and their children.

Often speaking more in sorrow than anger, a group of three dozen women acknowledged that record during an afternoon protest at the Allegheny County Courthouse.

“Sen. Casey certainly respects women,” said Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner, a Democrat. But “with respect must come trust” in women’s choices.

Several speakers, including a midwife and an obstetrician, argued that women seeking abortions after the 20th week typically did so only after learning of debilitating birth defects. Others warned that Mr. Casey was betraying his own political base.

Advertise with us

Ms. Jeffrey told the crowd that “Democratic leaders have risen to power on the backs of black women,” citing a December upset by Democrat Doug Jones in a special U.S. Senate election in Alabama. “We are telling you that our bodies, our voices and our lives matter.”

S.B. 2311 was expected to fail. Under Senate rules, it had to clear a procedural hurdle that requires 60 votes, and got only 51. Mr. Casey voted for a similar bill in 2015.

But the vote was timed to put Democrats like him on the defensive, and conservatives seem unlikely to let the issue go.

In September, a group of three dozen anti-abortion activists protested outside Mr. Casey’s Pittsburgh office, due largely to his defense of federal funding for non-abortion services at Planned Parenthood. That history was cited in a statement Monday by the state Republican Party, which argued Mr. Casey’s “record affirms that he is not a pro-life Democrat.”

Planned Parenthood did not participate in Monday’s event, which organizers called a grassroots effort. In a statement, the group’s Pennsylvania political affiliate expressed support for “activists who wanted to express their frustration and disappointment. … We’re all on the same page: We know what happens when politicians stand in the way of access to comprehensive reproductive health care.”

Ms. Wagner said that despite this week’s vote, “of course we’ll all support” Mr. Casey in November. But, she added, “It will be hard to do with the enthusiasm that we have for everything else he’s done.”