Democrats may not be universally popular in solidly conservative Upper St. Clair. But after a police officer mistakenly warned residents about displaying political signs there last week, local officials stress that backing political candidates of either party is not against the law.

Upper St. Clair resident Jennifer Schnore and her husband, Peter, were among those who put out lawn signs touting Democrat Conor Lamb last week. Mr. Lamb is running against Republican Rick Saccone in a special election in the 18th Congressional District set for March 13. But the Schnores had a rude awakening the morning of Jan. 12.

“My husband said the sign had been removed and placed -- placed very nicely -- in the driveway,” Ms. Schnore said Tuesday, explaining that she though kids were responsible. But later that day, “when I opened the mailbox, there was a written warning” from police.

The “visitation warning” cited township zoning code to assert “Political signs may not be posted more than 30 days prior to an election.” Ms. Schnore soon found a pair of fellow Democrats who’d also received the warnings, and social media began crackling with concern.

Advertise with us

Upper St. Clair Police Chief Doug Burkholder ascribed the situation to “misinterpretation of the code by one of our newer officers. I’ve talked to the officer and it’s all on hold.

“We don’t have any campaign to slight one candidate or the other,” stressed Chief Burkholder, who said he’d put enforcement on hiatus after getting a call from a resident.

“The sky is not falling,” he said. “I don’t think we have people protesting -- let me look out my office window. Nope, we don’t.”

But by Tuesday, the ACLU of Pennsylvania had sent a letter to township officials.

“Upper St. Clair cannot prohibit any home dwellers (owners or renters) from displaying political signs,” said the letter, written by ACLU legal director Witold “Vic” Walczak. “If we receive even a single complaint, your next notice will be a federal court lawsuit.”

Advertise with us

The letter cited a number of precedents -- including a 2000 federal case in which the ACLU sued Upper St. Clair over its sign policy.

That case involved an artist who opposed deer hunting in the community, and who received a “cease and desist” warning from the township by displaying an image of “Bambi being shot,” Mr. Walczak said in an interview. The subsequent federal court dispute ultimately ended in a settlement, in which township officials agreed to change zoning codes.

In a statement, township manager Matthew Serakowski said that last week a USC officer “mistakenly issued warnings regarding political signs” -- an error officials corrected after one day. “The township is committed to upholding all individuals’ right of free speech and has not required the removal of any political signs due to the timing of their placement.”

Mr. Walczak said it’s not unusual for communities to try to rein in political signage: “We send between a handful to a couple dozen letters like this every year.” But this was the first time since the 2000 case in which it had been an issue for Upper St. Clair.

In a statement, the Lamb campaign said it wouldn’t comment on legal matters, “But we appreciate voters’ eagerness to show their support for Conor Lamb.”