In some parts of the country, Republicans were hit by an electoral tsunami on Tuesday. In Virginia, they lost a governor’s race, and their advantage in the state Legislature was all but swept away. In Philadelphia’s suburbs, the tidal wave pummeled long-held Republican dominance in local and county offices: Republicans in four county offices were swamped just in Chester County, home of state Republican chairman Val DiGiorgio.
Democrats there were quick to see that outcome as a referendum on a Republican not named on the ballot: President Donald Trump. But the anti-Republican tide ebbed before the waters reached Western Pennsylvania. And it's unclear how candidates should navigate the campaigns of 2018.
“Statewide, things were great,” said Republican Committee of Allegheny County chair D. Raja, citing Republican Supreme Court Justice Sallie Mundy’s win over Allegheny County family court Judge Dwayne Woodruff.
Locally, Mr. Raja said, “We had some disappointments” -- including the defeat of County Councilman Ed Kress north of Pittsburgh. “But other things went well,” like nearly sweeping borough council and school board races in Plum.
Still, progressives too showed strength. Mr. Kress was defeated by Anita Prizio, who was backed by an upstart local chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America. (DSA-backed lawyer Mik Pappas also won a race against longtime Pittsburgh District Judge Ron Costa.) Erie, meanwhile, elected the state’s first transgender officeholder, Tyler Titus, to school board.
Mr. Raja’s counterpart, county Democratic chair Nancy Patton Mills, noted Democratic gains in races in Moon Township and Mt. Lebanon’s school board. Both communities fall in the 18th congressional district, where a special election to replace Republican Tim Murphy will be held next year.
“I think it’s going to be exciting for us next year,” she said. “Trump voters in outlying counties may not be feeling [discontent] yet, but suburban communities may be starting to feel the difference.”
During a pre-election stop in Pittsburgh the weekend before the election, Democratic National Committee vice-chair Michael Blake said the outcome Nov. 7 “will demonstrate what is the momentum on the ground against Trump. … And it will give us guidance about what kind of races to run in 2018.”
The guidance, pundits agreed before all the ballots were even counted, was that voters in affluent suburbs were revolting against Mr. Trump. Suburbanites in Northern Virginia blasted GOP gubernatorial candidate Ed Gillespie.
In Philadelphia’s suburbs, “Republicans are doing what Democrats have been doing in the southwest: either changing their registration or voting outside their party,” said Franklin & Marshall College pollster Terry Madonna. While that trend has long been underway among the area’s more moderate voters, he said, “Anti-Trump sentiment is accelerating it.”
“Trump is very weak and getting weaker in affluent areas with high levels of educational attraction,” agreed Kyle Kondik, who studies and predicts election trends at the University of Virginia Center for Politics. But Mr. Gillespie did well in more Appalachian parts of that state, he said, adding that “Western Pennsylvania is Appalachian too, and it’s been trending Republican for years.”
Mr. Kondik said a better gauge for political sentiment here would be the battle to replace Mr. Murphy, whose district has above-average income and educational levels. “Republicans are strongly favored to hold it. But if there’s considerable erosion in GOP performance, that will tell us more about Western Pennsylvania.”
Judicial races, after all, often fail to predict future results. In 2015, Democrats swept all the statewide judicial races on the ballot -- and then went on to suffer crushing losses in the race for president and senate the next year.
As for this year’s Supreme Court race, many Democrats privately conceded it months ago: Judge Woodruff struggled with fundraising and a low-visibility ground game. Despite having earned a Super Bowl ring as a Steeler, he lost every southwestern Pennsylvania county except Allegheny. Ms. Mills ascribed that outcome to a late-breaking Republican ad accusing the judge of nepotism.
Further down-ballot, the tea leaves are harder to read. Democrats won three of four Superior Court seats and split a pair of Commonwealth Court seats with Republicans. At the municipal level, Democrats won two key races in Erie. But Democratic County Executive Kathy Dahlkemper beat her rival by less than half a percentage point. Erie mayoral candidate Joe Schember’s less than 7-point win over John Persinger was comparatively tight in a staunchly Democratic city.
Once reliably Democratic, Erie County backed Donald Trump in 2016, a reversal that put a dagger through Hillary Clinton’s chances. Even with a solid base in the southeast, That may be a concern for the reelection chances of Gov. Tom Wolf and Sen. Bob Casey next year.
Mr. Casey has long opposed the trade deals that Mr. Trump also campaigned against last year, and “he should have strong legs to stand on” next year, said Andrew Bloeser, a political science professor at Allegheny College not far from Erie County. “Erie is becoming more competitive, but I don’t know that it’s turning red.”
“If people are concerned that [Mr. Trump’s] bluster has done nothing for their economic concerns, that may not bode well for him or those down ballot” next year, he said.
Still, polling suggests that Mr. Trump is, at least for now, mostly holding on to his white working-class base. And while Republicans elsewhere may fret about his impact on 2018, Mr. Raja said that even after Tuesday, “I’m still hearing a very much pro-Trump message.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.