Gerrymandering is not an issue typically associated with Grassroots Pittsburgh, a community-based, politically progressive community group that lobbies for universal health care, immigrant and minority rights, voter rights and environmental issues.
But combating gerrymandering, the reconfiguring of legislative and congressional districts to favor one political party, has now become a priority for the group, said Jacob Mirra, Grassroots Pittsburgh’s vice president and co-organizer.
“It sort of had to be,” said Mr. Mirra. “We just feel like we couldn’t get the changes we wanted unless we got to the root of the issue. Politicians will not be responsive to voters as long as they have the ability to choose their voters.”
Grassroots Pittsburgh on Sunday sponsored a forum on gerrymandering at the University of Pittsburgh, but let the independent, non-partisan Fair Districts PA do most of the talking.
Fair Districts PA wants to see a revamping of the state commission responsible for drawing district boundaries so that one political party can’t pack the opposing party’s supporters into one district, then surround it with multiple districts of their own, resulting in more legislative seats in Harrisburg.
Moderator David Misra, a spokesman for Fair Districts and a political science instructor for the Community College of Allegheny County, said Pennsylvania is commonly listed as one of the most gerrymandered states in the nation.
As one example, Mr. Misra pointed to Pennsylvania’s 7th Congressional District outside Philadelphia, whose Rorschach test-like borders incorporate parts of five, predominantly white counties but at one point is only 700 feet wide.
Legislative and congressional boundaries are redrawn every 10 years, based on census numbers, and the 7th District “is unrecognizable right now” from its previous compact shape, he said.
In that regard, Republicans have outmaneuvered Democrats, targeting state legislative elections so that they now hold majorities in 43 states including Pennsylvania, where Republicans have 13 of the state’s 18 congressional seats despite getting 54 percent of the total votes cast in the last election.
“They were smart and they were ready,” Mr. Misra said, “and Democrats kind of fell asleep at the switch.”
But he noted that Democrats have caught on and used the same strategy to bolster their legislative majority in Maryland.
“They are not necessarily any more pure than the Republicans,” he said.
Another speaker, state Rep. Dan Frankel, D-Squirrel Hill, said having secure districts puts more emphasis on primary elections, which favor more ideologically rigid candidates who are less willing to compromise once elected.
“That makes it harder to govern” and leads to legislative gridlock, he said.
Two bills in the Pennsylvania Legislature are calling for an independent redistricting commission, and a separate lawsuit is challenging the state’s congressional district map.
But Mr. Misra said the best hope for addressing gerrymandering concerns lies with a Wisconsin case before the U.S. Supreme Court, Gill v. Whitford, challenging that state’s reapportionment that assured Republicans would remain in control.
“This is not about payback,” he said. “It’s about fixing this so we don’t have any more shenanigans.”
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.