Ineligible legal immigrants voted in the 2016 elections in Allegheny County, but the three the county has found made up just .00046 percent of the 654,849 ballots cast here, according to elections officials.
The Allegheny County Elections Department found that 98 immigrants have registered in Allegheny since 2006: In Philadelphia, more than 300 had.
County workers compiled the numbers after the Philadelphia Inquirer and the Post-Gazette reported that some immigrants, who were in Pennsylvania legally but not as citizens, had been able to register to vote.
That has alarmed some Republicans, who say it proves the election system is prone to fraud.
“It's more evidence that we have a problem," said Hans von Spakovsky, a member of President Donald Trump’s Presidential Advisory Commission on Election Integrity.
Interviewed after a Wednesday-night debate on immigraton at the University of Pittsburgh, Mr. Spakovsky noted that officials only discovered the immigrant voters because those voters later sought to withdraw their registration.
"It's the tip of the iceberg,” he said.
Officials surmise that most immigrants register by mistake, often while obtaining a driver’s license. The state’s “motor voter” law gives drivers a chance to register at PennDOT offices, but while legal immigrants can obtain a license, they are barred from voting.
Immigrants may discover the error when later applying for citizenship: They withdraw their registration to get on the right side of the law.
“It’s a really serious situation,” said Pittsburgh immigration attorney Vanessa Caruso. If an immigrant votes without a compelling explanation, “You have pretty much sealed your fate” as far as seeking future citizenship. “I’m always quick to tell them you have no right to vote.”
On Thursday afternoon, Allegheny County Election Director Mark Wolosik said elections staff had researched the voting records of 85 of the 98 immigrant voters they knew of. Of those, 59 had never voted at all. Nine had voted in one of the past three presidential elections; one had voted in all three.
Sam DeMarco, a Republican County Councilman who sits on the county’s Elections Board, called the situation “very concerning,” and said he’d ask for a more thorough review.
“People will compare it to the turnout for a presidential election, and say it’s miniscule,” said Mr. DeMarco. “But many races at the municipal or school board level are decided by 10 votes or less. … If you found out that your vote had been canceled out by someone who wasn’t legally allowed to vote, how would you feel?”
On Wednesday, Pennsylvania’s Department of State issued a statement saying election officials “had already taken action to reduce the likelihood of such occurrences.” The department said that in 2016, it made computerized voter-registration instructions clearer, to reduce confusion for immigrants.
“We think this problem has been taken care of,” agreed ACLU of Pennsylvania Legal Director Vic Walczak, who has fought in court over voting rights.
“There is a problem with elections, but it’s not fraud,” he said. “It’s glitches, it’s human error, and it’s not having the resources for something as important as elections.”
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.