She’s been a city councilwoman, a school board member, and a Democratic committeewoman. Yet when mayoral candidate Darlene Harris says, “I never really turned into a politician, I’m still the community advocate,” there is some truth to it.
Her campaign to oust Mayor Bill Peduto, after all, hosts neither rallies nor a website. Her vision for Pittsburgh is simplicity itself: “It’s going to be what you as the communities are looking to have done.”
Her game plan is equally straightforward: Attack the incumbent. When asked about abortion at an April 27 forum, for example, she said she was pro-life, and added, “Also, if I’m elected mayor, I’ll be here instead of traveling the world” — her latest riff on how often the mayor appears at conferences elsewhere.
Mr. Peduto, whose travel costs are paid for by event sponsors, typically brushes off such accusations. Mrs. Harris’ mayoral bid faces long odds. But some say she could serve as a Pittsburgh-inflected voice for some working-class residents figuring out their place in a post-industrial city.
“There’s a culture clash between the old and new,” said Doug Shields, a former city councilor who caucused with Mr. Peduto but later worked as a consultant for Mrs. Harris. “The city wants to promote itself as a high-tech, foodie place. But there are people saying, ‘What about me?’ ”
Mrs. Harris — and she prefers “Mrs.” to “Ms.” — began learning her North Side district at an early age, where her family bounced around neighborhoods until settling in Spring Hill. It is there, in the house once owned by her grandmother, that she began as a neighborhood activist with the Spring Hill Civic League more than 30 years ago.
After efforts that included establishing an umbrella organization of North Side groups to increase their clout, she ran for school board in 1995. There, she worked to stabilize district finances and espoused “neighborhood schools,” smaller school buildings closer to home.
One of Mrs. Harris’ allies on the board, Theresa Colaizzi, said the push for neighborhood schools was “about people wanting to stay together as a community.” Mrs. Harris, she said, “always knew her stuff.”
But Mrs. Harris and others fought with the superintendent, John Thompson: The bitterness prompted local foundations to suspend funding of district programs. Many residents saw neighborhood schools “as resegregation,” said Randall Taylor, an African-American former board member who often opposed Mrs. Harris.
While he called her “a worthy adversary,” he said “she represents a strain in the city that wants things to stay a certain way, and doesn’t always see the effect on others.”
“People felt I was doing what I was there to do: represent them,” Mrs. Harris said. “And what I heard from everyone was they wanted neighborhood schools.”
Mrs. Harris was ousted in 2003 by Patrick Dowd. “We said she creates negative publicity without changing anything for the better,” said Don Friedman, a Dowd campaign consultant.
But Mr. Friedman, who lives in Spring Hill, said when it comes to neighborhood needs, “If you call Darlene, she gets something done.”
And when Luke Ravenstahl, then the council president, ascended to the mayor’s office after the 2006 death of Bob O’Connor, Mrs. Harris took his council seat.
“We really showed her, didn’t we?” Mr. Friedman joked.
Between 2010 and 2011, Mrs. Harris and Mr. Peduto were allies, after she joined his faction to became council president.
Legislation Mr. Peduto still celebrates, like a 2010 prevailing-wage ordinance for employers in subsidized developments, was passed during that period.
“Darlene’s a workhorse,” said city councilman Bruce Kraus.
While he later replaced her as council president, and has gaveled her down in a series of sometimes ugly disputes, he called her “a street-smart fighter” and said “I wouldn’t fault her work ethic.”
But relations between Mr. Peduto and Mrs. Harris soured, and when Mr. Peduto won the 2013 Democratic primary to replace the outgoing Mr. Ravenstahl, Mrs. Harris weighed challenging him in November, briefly registering as an independent before abandoning the idea
This year, she has allied with police, who are often at odds with Mr. Peduto. She has said she would defer to commanders on issues like releasing police camera footage to the public.
“We really need to let them do their job, not micromanage what they are doing,” she said.
“Darlene sees the police as the experts, and that’s a problem,” said Brandi Fisher, president of the Alliance for Police Accountability. “We want to respect their input, but it shouldn’t be more important than the input of the community.”
But Mrs. Harris’ campaign has perhaps been most defined by her opposition to bike lanes, a signature Peduto initiative. During a WTAE-TV debate, she chastised moderators for not raising the issue, and online video of Mrs. Harris yelling at a cyclist from her car went viral.
“I don’t hate people that ride bikes,” she said. “I have a problem with putting in bike lanes and not having safety or traffic studies.”
A spokeswoman for Mr. Peduto said the city conducts a traffic analysis before any major street change, and Bike Pittsburgh executive director Scott Bricker said city bike lanes “follow the proper guidelines” set by national groups.
“This election is the first time that people have been attacking what we do,” he added.
Mrs. Harris faces her own bumpy road, partly because Mr. Peduto’s campaign has over $700,000 in the bank. Mrs. Harris is ignoring a city law that requires monthly reporting of financial activities, so her current finances are unavailable. But when asked why she didn’t have a website, she said, “those things cost money.”
Mrs. Harris also lost the endorsement of the Democratic Party committee, a serious setback for the longtime chair of the North Side’s 26th Ward. Eileen Kelly, the city committee’s top Democrat, said “I don’t think an incumbent mayor has lost the endorsement,” adding that Mrs. Harris’ brief party switch in 2013 also may have hurt. “I don’t understand why she did that.”
Still, Mrs. Kelly called Mrs. Harris “one of the few women leaders in Pittsburgh politics,” and said she appealed to union members and working-class voters. Mrs. Harris, meanwhile, says she won’t change who she is for the sake of a campaign.
“What you see,” she said, “is what you get.”
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.