Driving the rural lane to his sister’s farmhouse in Butler County today for the annual family Thanksgiving gathering, Jeff Swensen won’t be surprised to feel a little uneasy.
The liberal Democrat, a 52-year-old photojournalist, has had some raw political rows in recent years with Republican members of his family, mainly his parents. With the wounds from the polarizing Trump-Clinton presidential campaign still fresh, any such talk could be more troublesome than usual. After all, sharp cutting knives will be within reach.
“Usually I’m telling myself I need to keep my mouth shut and not be baited into an argument, which is easily done with me,” says Mr. Swensen, who nonetheless loves his family and will be driving from Oakmont to join them with his similarly liberal wife and three children.
His father, Harold Swensen, 83, one of Pittsburgh’s most prominent surgeons before his retirement, won’t mind a bit if politics comes up before, during or after dinner. He grew up in a household where debates — or frequent arguments — over such topics were common. The Fox Chapel Republican who voted for Donald Trump, though he wasn’t happy about his party’s choice of nominee, considers any such talk one more opportunity to talk some sense into his son.
“I don’t understand how someone could grow up in this house and have some of the ideas he has,” Dr. Swensen laments. “But I’m not troubled by getting angry or upset or having a difference of opinion — it’s almost a rush to me.”
Whether the Swensen clan’s version of talking turkey this year will include talking Trump — and how that will go, if so — was still unclear at this writing. Theirs is hardly the only household likely to wrestle with the issue during the post-election holidays of 2016. How many will give thanks today, after all, for experiencing what feels like one of the most divisive periods in America since the Vietnam War?
Read More
Members of some families will simply skip participation in the traditional meal because they’ve been hardcore Trump or Clinton supporters who can’t fathom being among relatives on the other side who outnumber them. A colleague at this newspaper even volunteered to work a holiday shift so as not to share meat and potatoes — and discussion — with a parent of opposing ideology.
Some families may set boundaries that put the recent election off-limits, preferring a less contentious topic to discuss with mouths full: Who’s to blame in the Brad Pitt-Angelina Jolie divorce? Did Bob Dylan really deserve a Nobel Prize for literature? Why, dear God, are the Steelers so bad against bad teams (except the Browns)?
If the talk turns political, that will undoubtedly trouble some people, Dr. Swensen aside. A post-election ABC News survey found 14 percent of respondents would find political discourse over Thanksgiving dinner “very” stressful and another 24 percent “somewhat” stressful. In a separate online survey, conducted by the Meyocks marketing firm, 30 percent of people wanted the topic to be taboo today.
If the latter is true, would it be best for a host or hostess to just make a preemptive declaration to guests that politics is off the table? Um, probably not, according to some advisers.
“Pre-empting conflict, in my experience, brings on more conflict,” said Lynn MacBeth, a Pittsburgh lawyer and family mediator. “I would be careful about saying anything at the outset, because that’s just going to open up the wound.”
She added, however, that people should anticipate the recent election as a likely topic of discussion. Planning comments that can be delivered in an unemotional way, so as to avoid arguing, would be a good idea, Ms. MacBeth said. If attendees can come up with a good political joke or other means of keeping the conversation light, so much the better.
“I would say the No. 1 rule is to remember your values, and you value your loved ones not because of their political beliefs but because of the love you have and the important relationships you have that overlap,” she said. “There’s just too much at stake to put politics first.”
Erin Yanacek and her husband will be hosting their parents at their Greenfield home in their first Thanksgiving as newlyweds. Her father will be the lone Republican, she says, and with some hard-core leftists present, he and she know it will be best not to make the election results part of the family discourse.
“I’m definitely the only one allowed to talk to my dad about politics,” she said, and father and daughter are likely to do that privately on a jog together. If anyone goes rogue at dinner by mentioning the names Trump or Clinton, said Ms. Yanacek, 27, “the rest of us would quickly spring into action to change the subject.”
Arthur Zipris, a psychologist and family therapist with the Western Pennsylvania Family Center, said each family’s ability to handle the topic will vary according to how mature its members have been in the past in handling disagreements. Every family has tensions, he said, and relatives have to learn how to maintain composure without lashing out during disagreements.
“The way to help the family is not by trying to get people to have the correct opinion, but to manage yourself,” Mr. Zipris said.
Like Ms. MacBeth, he advised thinking ahead about the right thing to say if the election comes up, to help avoid the kind of offensive or defensive statements that might create long-lasting scars.
“People don’t go into battle without going to boot camp first, or go to the Olympics without training, so prepare yourself on how to be more thoughtful,” Mr. Zipris said.
Jeff Swensen, who spent a good portion of this year photographing Trump rallies despite a visceral dislike for the president-elect, said he’s so aghast at some of his relatives’ politics — and at how emotional he believes some of them get — that it makes it hard to maintain his own composure. He believes the family may do some “walking on eggshells” when gathering today.
“We could have World War III, or everybody could just laugh and say, ‘Thank heavens we’re all together,’ ” he said.
His father acknowledges he himself gets “probably a little more touchy” with Jeff than with other people, because “you’re less likely to put up with certain things with a son.”
But Dr. Swensen also believes everyone will manage just fine at the annual gathering in Middlesex today, based on their mutual caring. And in the unlikely event that cutlery enters the equation, the longtime orthopedic surgeon just chuckled at the prospect: “Oh, I’d have the advantage there.”
Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.