It has been two weeks since Pennsylvania Sen. Pat Toomey announced his opposition to the controversial Trans Pacific Partnership trade deal. Now he and his Democratic rival, Katie McGinty, are trading allegations of hypocrisy.
On Wednesday, Ms. McGinty joined with allies at the Allegheny County Courthouse to tout an economic plan that included investments in green energy, infrastructure and job training. But she devoted much of her time to attacking Mr. Toomey, who she said “has supported every single trade deal going.”
Though long a champion of free trade, Mr. Toomey first publicly opposed the TPP in an Aug. 17 Post-Gazette editorial, saying it was “not … a good enough deal for Pennsylvania workers.” But on Wednesday, Ms. McGinty called that “a bunch of baloney,” citing his 2015 vote giving President Barack Obama “fast track” authority to conclude the trade pact with 11 other countries.
By passing the measure, Congress waived its ability to amend the treaty, though it would still have to ratify the deal in an up-or-down vote.
At the time of the fast-track vote, much of the TPP was completed, though key sticking points remained — including intellectual-property protections that Mr. Toomey ultimately said were too weak. But given worries about the pact’s impact on jobs, Ms. McGinty said, it was “unconscionable … that there be no amendments to a deal like that.”
Ms. McGinty was joined Wednesday by Democrats including Braddock Mayor John Fetterman. While he’d been Ms. McGinty’s rival during the Democratic primary, he called Mr. Toomey’s TPP stance “one of the greatest flip-flops of all time.”
Republicans have accused Ms. McGinty of her own trade policy hypocrisy. She supported NAFTA, a trade pact the U.S. joined with Mexico and Canada, while working in the White House of President Bill Clinton. (The agreement, she said in 1994, was “all about strong economic growth” and environmental protections.)
Mr. Fetterman himself criticized Ms. McGinty’s support during the primary, prompting Toomey spokesman Ted Kwong to say Wednesday, “Even John Fetterman has called out Katie McGinty’s fraudulent rhetoric on trade.” The statement also faulted Ms. McGinty’s tenure as chief of staff for Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Wolf, whose 2014 budget included tax hikes that “would have slammed Pennsylvania families and killed jobs.”
Ms. McGinty has previously said NAFTA didn't deliver the hoped-for benefits, and that has contributed to her opposition to the TPP.
Mr. Fetterman, for his part, said Mr. Toomey’s deep support of free trade was clear in his 2009 book, “The Road to Prosperity.” Copies were selling for a penny online, Mr. Fetterman added, saying, “No one is buying it on Amazon, and we aren’t buying it in the Mon Valley.”
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.