For a generation, Christian conservative activists played such a central role in Republican presidential campaigns that the GOP has been called America’s first religious party. They opposed abortion and same-sex marriage and supported the party’s opposition to legal recognition of those two issues. And they promoted public recognition of religion, such as courthouse displays of the Ten Commandments and school recitations of the Pledge of Allegiance with its “under God” clause.
While these were hardly the only issues on Republican platforms, they were central to many voters.
This year, so much has been scrambled.
It’s not just that Donald Trump, who is nobody’s idea of a religious conservative, has gathered surprisingly strong support among self-described born-again Christians — and among Republican Catholics, no matter what Pope Francis says about those who build walls.
And it’s not just the campaign mud-slinging, name-calling and anatomical boasts.
It’s also that the issues themselves have shifted.
Read More
Yes, Mr. Trump, the billionaire businessman, has courted religious conservative leaders such as Jerry Falwell Jr., though many other evangelical leaders have opposed him. And Mr. Trump has pledged to “protect Christianity,” which he says is “under siege.” But he has built his lead in delegates toward the GOP nomination by capturing and stirring anger over government, politicians, the economy and by targeting illegal immigrants and Muslims for exclusion.
Ted Cruz, the U.S. senator from Texas with the pedigree of a pastor’s son and fluency in biblical vocabulary, is making a strong appeal for Christian conservatives’ votes, but their votes had been spread thinly across multiple candidates until they began dropping out.
Abortion appears a back-burner issue this year. And whereas a decade ago, a sure vote-getter in many states was to propose a constitutional amendment restricting marriage to heterosexual couples, nobody is seriously pushing such a response to the 2015 U.S. Supreme Court decision legalizing same-sex marriage. That’s in recognition that Americans have radically shifted toward affirming same-sex relationships.
Instead, religious conservatives are now taking a defensive posture. They’re calling for religious-freedom protections that would enable wedding vendors and others to conscientiously object to catering to same-sex marriages.
A similar argument is being advanced in a pending case before the Supreme Court, brought by faith-based charities and schools seeking to opt out of the contraception mandate in Obamacare.
Even so, such matters aren’t political drivers this campaign.
“I don’t think social issues have played nearly the kind of role they had in the past,” said Terry Madonna, director of the Franklin & Marshall College Poll. “Overall, the focus has largely been on the economy. The whole dynamic seems to be playing out on domestic politics more than the great social issues of our time.”
He added that in recent polls “social issues are 1-3 percent top of mind. They’re just not simply there.”
He said we shouldn’t be shocked that many evangelicals are drawn to Mr. Trump’s talking points.
“If I’m an evangelical or born-again Christian, why can’t I also care about whether my party has let me down, whether my voice is being heard?” he said.
Concern about government and politicians has soared among voters in the Franklin & Marshall polls, and no wonder, he said.
“Look what’s happened in Harrisburg,” he said. “It’s the definition of dysfunction. Then go to the dysfunctionality in Washington.”
The Democratic race has also been defined by issues of economic equality raised by Bernie Sanders in his challenge to Hillary Clinton. In past elections, Democrats have built coalitions of religious and racial minorities and those with no religious affiliation, and candidate rhetoric has focused more on shared values than a particular religious identity.
In a Franklin & Marshall Poll survey conducted earlier this month, more than one-third of registered Republican voters identified as “born-again” or “fundamentalist” Christians, while only 12 percent of Democrats did.
On the Republican side, Mr. Cruz and Mr. Trump each drew about one- third of born-again supporters compared with only 18 percent for John. Kasich. Mr. Trump also had the highest Catholic support at 37 percent, to Mr. Kasich’s 28 percent and Mr. Cruz’s 19 percent.
Among Democrats, Ms. Clinton led across religious categories.
“By and large, the conservative-faith vote, for lack of a better category, still favors Cruz, but it’s not overwhelming,” said Paul Kengor, executive director of the Center for Vision & Values at Grove City College and author of several books on presidential politics.
Mr. Kengor, like others, speculates that Mr. Trump’s self-described evangelical supporters are those who traditionally have been less engaged in church and political activism. Mr. Kengor regularly attends functions among conservative evangelicals and Catholics, and “I can count on one hand” the Trump supporters.
In fact, when Mr. Trump made his soon-retracted statement favoring penalties for women who have abortions, “he was revealing his ignorance of a group whose vote he’s trying to get,” he said. “That outraged pro-life conservatives” who needed to reassure others that “we don’t support that.”
At Geneva College, a small evangelical school in Beaver Falls, students are paying close attention to the campaign and trying their best not to be jaded.
“This whole election has been a little weird, because a lot of people I supported dropped out,” said Wes Thompson in a group interview with several soon-to-graduate seniors at the campus dining hall.
“I was a Rubio fan. I liked Ben Carson a lot. It’s sad to say that toward the national election, I might wind up choosing who’s going to harm us the least,” he lamented.
He would like to see a candidate with the “attitude of a servant,” but he and his classmates agreed the closest fit to that description is Bernie Sanders, whose socialist economic views they can’t support.
None of those gathered at the table were Trump supporters.
“It’s hard for me to take what he says seriously, because he’s said some polarizing things and hateful things against groups,” including immigrants, said Charissa Garner of Lafayette Hill. While she recognizes that illegal immigration needs to be addressed, “America has always been known as a welcoming place.”
Many were appalled by campaign rhetoric.
“Seriously? You’re running for president, and you’re comparing your wife to someone else’s wife?” said Katie Grunza of Clementine, N.J., of a recent Trump kerfuffle with a pro-Cruz organization.
Brett Williams of Gettysburg said he likes Mr. Kasich, the Ohio governor, as much as anything for his substantive answers during debates that otherwise seem given over to shouting matches. “Why is this guy the third wheel?” he asked.
Kacie Moore of Doylestown, Ohio, who already voted in her state’s primary, said that for her, the choice for Mr. Cruz was clear.
“One thing I really value about him is he said he would come to office with two books,” the Bible and the Constitution, she said.
Geneva College is one of the plaintiffs (along with the lead plaintiff, Bishop David Zubik of the Pittsburgh Roman Catholic diocese) in a pending Supreme Court case that’s become a symbol of the growing appeals among conservative Christians for religious liberty. The organizations are seeking exemptions on moral grounds from provisions in the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare, requiring the inclusion of contraceptives for female students and employees on their health insurance plans.
More broadly, some states have passed recent legislation seeking to exempt wedding vendors such as bakers from being required to cater to same-sex couples.
For Mr. Williams, it’s important to support a presidential candidate who at least understands such concerns.
“So often, Christians and religious people in general are being called out as bigots,” he said. “I feel it’s necessary for me to feel comfortable that somebody is not going to be in office who has that view.”
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.