Daryl Metcalfe of Cranberry, who has proudly described himself as “the” most conservative legislator in Harrisburg, is facing what arguably could be the toughest Republican primary contest in his nine terms as representative for the 12th District.
His opponent, Gordon Marburger, has one of the most recognizable surnames in Western Pennsylvania thanks to his family’s dairy products, stocked in groceries throughout the region. And Mr. Marburger knows his way around the political stump: He is a longtime school board member in the Mars Area School District and is married to a 16-year veteran county official, Butler County Treasurer Diane Marburger.
Mr. Marburger, 59, of Adams, came close to winning the Republican nomination for the seat in the 2014 primary, even though a protocol error forced him off the ballot and into the uphill climb of a write-in candidacy.
Mr. Metcalfe, 53, also has a healthy bank of name recognition, in large part because of his take-no-prisoners approach to representing his constituents, including actions such as these:
• Filing a court action a few weeks ago against state Rep. Peter Daley, D-Washington/Fayette, in a brief legal battle over Mr. Metcalfe’s allegation that Mr. Daley ghost-voted during the December budget battle;
• Attempting in 2013 to prevent state Rep. Brian Sims, D-Philadelphia, an openly gay legislator, from speaking on the House floor about gay marriage, saying such a speech would be an “open rebellion against Almighty God”;
• Referring to “illegal alien invaders” when talking about immigration on his website, supporting the suspension of the license of any care facility that shelters unaccompanied immigrant children;
• Trying to rally support such initiatives as declaring English as the official language in Pennsylvania.
His far-right brand of Republicanism may have, in the past, whipped the support of his Republican-dominated district, which essentially is the southern strip of Butler County. But the appeal may be fading as he seeks his 10th two-year term. In the 2014 primary, Mr. Marburger, a fifth-generation farmer and bus driver who is a trustee on the board of Butler County Community College, came within about 550 votes of winning the GOP nomination as a write-in candidate. He had been booted off the primary ballot because he failed to properly file an ethics form in Harrisburg, a mistake he blamed on a misunderstanding. He said he had filed the paperwork in Butler, the county seat.
Mr. Metcalfe said he is “well aware” of his naysayers’ criticisms that he is interested in spectacle over substance. But, he chalks up his opposition to wolves in sheeps’ clothing — Republicans who really don’t hold true to Republican ideals.
He said they fail to recognize that what appear to be national social issues, such as immigration, actually impact state residents’ pocketbooks: “We spend millions to educate these illegal aliens,” he said, adding that the cost rises when incarceration and social welfare expenses are added.
He takes credit for helping to beat back Gov. Tom Wolf’s plan to raise state taxes in the hotly contested budget battle. He said the most critical issue that faces taxpayers is the cost of government. “I’ve been an effective voice for the taxpayers of my district. We realized victories in stopping [Mr. Wolf’s] agenda … to increase taxes. … I will continue to do so if I’m re-elected.”
Referring to Mr. Marburger and his “accomplices,” he said, “they’ve tried to create this fallacy that a state legislator should work as a local mayor.” The comment responds to criticism that Mr. Metcalfe fails to battle for local issues.
“They want me to bring home the pork so they don’t have to increase local taxes,” he said in response to that criticism. He stressed that he remains true to a longtime political platform: “Limited, efficient government; less taxation; local control of education.”
Mr. Marburger, who said he sees eye to eye with his opponent on many traditional Republican principles, added that he also is a “realist.”
For example, he said, Mr. Metcalfe’s allegation that Mr. Marburger would have voted in favor of an increased gas tax two years ago is true. “Well, yeah, I don’t want to raise taxes. But what’s the alternative if you need to raise money for our roads? I guess we had to raise the gas tax. No one has shown any way of funding these important projects with the revenue we had.”
He said he holds to Republican values but will work with people from all parties and beliefs, noting that he has worked with members from both parties during the 11 years he has been on the Mars Area school board.
“Daryl’s biggest problem, his biggest failing, is that I just believe he is not listening to the people, all the people. We have some common beliefs: I’m pro-gun, small government. But, the law is the law. This anti-gay, anti-immigrant stuff — we’re having that discussion at church. … We’re in the discernment process. But, they’re still part of your constituents. … He expensed a trip to Arizona for an immigration conference. I think that’s a little overboard. That’s not a 12th District issue. Immigration is a federal responsibility. Gay marriage, maybe it breaks with the belief of the Bible but, well, follow the law,” Mr. Marburger said.
“I’m conservative, but I’m able and willing to listen, and I’m able and willing to compromise. Both sides have to meet, discuss and move a little bit to get things done. Daryl is an embarrassment. It’s his way or no way. If you don’t see it his way, he’s coming after you. Basically, he’s just a big bully.”
Mr. Metcalfe, an Army veteran, acknowledges that he’s a fighter — for the members of his district. He is chairman of the House State Government Committee.
The primary election is April 26. Christian Rieger, a lawyer who lives in Cranberry, is the only candidate seeking the Democratic nomination for the 12th District seat.
Karen Kane: kkane@post-gazette.com or at 724-772-9180.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.