After months of campaigning, a loss in the Democratic primary and a write-in win for the Republican nomination, the incumbent in a Ross Board of Commissioners race ultimately lost the election in a matter of 20 seconds.
Paul Trilli and challenger Patrick Mullin, who tied with 359 votes each on Election Day for the spot representing the township's Seventh Ward, each drew numbers today from a leather shake bottle typically used in bottle pocket billiards.
The custom, called the casting of the lots, is the Allegheny County election bureau's official procedure for settling a draw. The person with the wooden number closest to 51 wins.
Mr. Mullin picked 32. Mr. Trilli picked 26.
"Yeah, baby, yeah!" yelled a friends of Mr. Mullin, who crowded around the table in the election office exactly at noon, per the election code.
Mr. Trilli, who was appointed to township commission in December 2013, called the process "unfair," saying the commissioners or voters in next May's primary should have chosen the winner.
"I think they need to revise it," he said of the process.
Minutes later, Mr. Mullin, standing in the hallway beside his wife, Robin, answered his cell phone: "I won!"
"This was a fair, fair, fair way, I thought," he said, adding. "I never even knew they did this."
Also today, Ernest Logan drew a 35, beating Donald Turner's 25 for Leetsdale constable, the only other tied race.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.