The race for Washington County commissioner has finally been decided -- two weeks after the election.

Republican candidate Mike McCormick said he conceded the race this morning to incumbent Democrat Harlan Shober, who was seeking a second four-year term on the three-member board.

Commissioners Larry Maggi, a Democrat, and Diana Irey Vaughan, a Republican, easily won re-election Nov. 3, but the battle for the third seat wavered between Mr. McCormick and Mr. Shober on election night and in the days afterward, when 815 absentee ballots and dozens of provisional ballots were counted. At one point, fewer than 30 votes separated the candidates.

The final tally from the county elections office, after counting the final 17 provisional ballots this morning, showed Mr. Shober with 16,609 votes to Mr. McCormick’s 16,574 votes.

Advertise with us

“I’m glad it’s finally over,” said Mr. Shober, 70, of Chartiers. “The process worked.”

Mr. McCormick, 66, of Peters, said he felt a challenge or request for a recount would be fruitless, based on the number of provisional ballots that were counted. Provisional ballots are given to people who aren’t on voter rolls due to clerical or other errors. An election canvassing board scrutinizes each ballot to determine whether the person is eligible to vote.

“We basically concluded that because of the effort of the elections board and staff that we were getting a fair count and the number is accurate and reliable,” Mr. McCormick said. “We didn’t feel the need for a recount.”

Mr. McCormick’s lawyer Sean Logue wasn’t as generous.

“I want to congratulate Diana Irey Vaughan and Mike McCormick for both running great races,” Mr. Logue said. “But I think that there are still some statistical anomalies that need to be investigated.”

Advertise with us

Specifically, Mr. Logue cited two tradionally Republican precincts in North Strabane and Peters, where only about half of the requested absentee ballots were returned.

“But every other precinct in the county had about a 90 percent return rate,” he said.

Anomalies notwithstanding, Mr. McCormick said he’s satisfied with the outcome and met with Mr. Shober this morning to discuss his ideas about dealing with the local drug epidemic.

“I asked him to take up the county’s biggest mantle -- a comprehensive drug strategy,” Mr. McCormick said. “I think we should be proactive, not reactive. We have a lot of damage being done to families and loved ones.”

Mr. Shober said he is open to discussing Mr. McCormick’s ideas further.

Advertise with us

“I am a very open person,” Mr. Shober said. “I’m always ready to listen to something that would better all of our lives.”

A political newcomer, Mr. McCormick said he will follow through with plans to step down at the end of the year as president and CEO of BenchMark Wealth Management, a firm he started 17 year ago.

He plans to focus more time and energy on a new initiative from his church for long-term community service projects.

Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1159.