Voters in Washington County will have some new choices Nov. 3 with four candidates on the ballot for county commissioner.

Though they represent different views and political parties, Republican incumbent Diana Irey Vaughan and Democratic incumbents Larry Maggi and Harlan Shober have formed a powerful triumvirate, with none of the squabbling, infighting and political treachery that had marked previous administrations.

Challengers see it as a tough nut to crack but the incumbents are proud of their rare arrangement, which emphasizes teamwork and a united front.

“We are not like Harrisburg, we’re not like D.C.,” said Mr. Maggi, 65, of Buffalo, who is seeking his fourth term in office. “We get along, we work well together and we like each other. Sometimes we’ve got to compromise, but we are all willing to do that. We’re very proud of that.”

Advertise with us

“We don’t always agree and we sometimes fight it out, but in the end, even if we disagree, we’re not going to throw anybody under the bus,” said Mr. Shober, 70, of Chartiers, who is seeking his second four-year term.

Trying to break into that united front is Republican Mike McCormick, 66, of Peters.

“Working together is what I would aspire to as a county commissioner,” said Mr. McCormick, CEO of BenchMark Wealth Management, a firm he started 17 years ago. “I admire the fact that they found a way to work together. Local issues transcend party loyalty.”

Voters will have a chance to choose among the four candidates — two from each party. The three who tally the most votes win.

Municipal election years often generate little voter interest or turnout, said Joseph DiSarro, chairman of the political science department at Washington &Jefferson College, who estimates that fewer than 40 percent of registered voters will turn out for the general election.

Advertise with us

That is a scenario that usually favors incumbents, Mr. DiSarro said, though a recent trend toward the GOP in voter registration might upset the apple cart.

“This is a conservative area that’s voted Republican in the past several Presidential elections,” said Mr. DiSarro, pointing to the steady rise of voters registering as Republican.

The GOP is still outnumbered by Democrats but the divide has gradually narrowed to 1.42 Democrats for every Republican. Ten years ago the margin was 2 to 1 in favor of Democrats.

“I don’t feel that will significantly impact this election,” he said of the GOP trend in the commissioner’s race. “The incumbents probably will stay in office. It’s so difficult to unseat an incumbent unless you have a high-profile race.”

But, if there’s any Republican that can win, Mr. DiSarro thinks it’s Mr. McCormick.

Advertise with us

“Mike McCormick has run a very, very intense campaign,” he said. “He’s worked hard at retail politics. He’s reached out to Republicans all over.”

Mr. McCormick thinks his business acumen would be a valuable asset in county government.

“I’m actually a political outsider whose never held a political office,” said Mr. McCormick, who waged aggressive but unsuccessful campaigns in 1994 and 1996 to unseat the late U.S. Rep. Frank Mascara for his congressional seat. “I want to take business thinking to county government to make it more efficient and effective.”

Mr. McCormick and the other candidates pointed to the local drug epidemic as the top issue for voters.  The county drew national media attention when 16 people overdosed on heroin during one day in August. Three of them died.

“We are currently under assault,” Mr. McCormick said. “Overdoses are at an all-time high.”

Advertise with us

The county’s drug problem, especially with heroin, was also highlighted by the other candidates. Each favored a plan to support the courts, district attorney and law enforcement with additional funding and programs.

“Instead of just putting people in jail, you put them into alternative services to try to help them,” said Mr. Shober,

Ms. Irey, 53, of Nottingham, has hosted re-entry conferences with human services and rehabilitation experts, to help former addicts get back on their feet with employment and other programs focused on issues such as obtaining housing, insurance and how to reinstate a suspended driver’s license.

“We’re working on some different approaches to reduce recidivism in our jail and drug use,” said Ms. Irey, the first and only woman to serve as a commissioner.  She is seeking her sixth term.  “We have start changing the way we’re delivering services.  We need to be open to trying more treatment options.”

Mr. Maggi said the county has begun funding rehabilitation and counseling services for defendants in jail, and using some of the $4 million to $5 million generated annually by Marcellus Shale gas impact fees to pay for additional probation officers and addiction services.

Advertise with us

“I’ve been on the tip of that spear,” said Mr. Maggi, who previously worked as a state police investigator and as the county sheriff before becoming commissioner.  “We are not winning that war. It’s really the scourge of our country.  Everyone is aware of it, from the president down to us.”

While the slowdown in gas well drilling in the Marcellus Shale has dampened profits for drillers and leasees this year, the county has absorbed the blow with little impact, incumbents said.

“I wouldn't say it’s a big deal, but it’s a concern,” Mr. Maggi said.  “We have those resources though, and we are always going to need energy.  It’s here to stay it’s not just short term.”

“We think we’re diversified enough, by drawing technology and manufacturing companies, that it’s not going to have a crippling effect on the county,” Ms. Irey said.

The incumbents said they have worked hard to keep taxes and unemployment rates low while helping the local economy grow.

Advertise with us

“I’ve balanced 17 budgets without a tax increase,” Ms. Irey said.

“We’re growing, we have been growing, and we want to continue growing smart,” Mr. Maggi said.  “We have a country charm here and we don’t want to give that up. That’s what brings people here.”

Mr. Shober encouraged voters to defy the odds and vote Nov. 3.

“No matter who you are for, we need people’s voices to be heard or it becomes a small percentage of people telling everyone how the government is going to be run,” he said.  “In the Middle East, people die waiting in line to vote.”

Mr. McCormick said he hopes voters will give him a chance.

Advertise with us

“The skills that will be necessary for the next 10 years are different from those needed in the past, and I think I am the best prepared to lead the county into the future,” he said. “Everyone else is talking about the past — I’m talking about the future.”

Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1159.