Four candidates are on the ballot in Westmoreland County on Nov. 3, seeking election to three vacancies on the Court of Common Pleas.

Judges Harry Smail Jr. of Greensburg and David Regoli of Lower Burrell, who were appointed to the seats by the governor in 2014, are running for full 10-year terms.

Greensburg attorney Scott Mears and state Rep. Tim Krieger of Delmont are the other two candidates.

All were cross-filed on both party ballots in the primary, and Mr. Mears, a Democrat, and Judge Smail, a Republican, won on both party ballots. Judge Regoli, a Democrat, won a Democratic nomination and Rep. Krieger, a Republican, won the third spot on the GOP ballot.

Advertise with us

County judges are paid $173,000 annually.

Judge Regoli, 50, is serving in civil court.

He said since Judge Smail and Mr. Mears are on both party ballots, he believes he and Mr. Krieger are vying for the third seat.

“So, I like to highlight the differences between us,” he said. “My 23 years of experience has been in trying cases. I’d say I have had a minimum of 150 non-jury and jury trials.

“To be a good trial judge, you have to be a good trial attorney first,” he said. “And I think that experience has allowed me to become a good judge in a short time because it’s given me the ability to resolve cases.

Advertise with us

“Today, for example, I had two pretrial conferences, and we settled both cases,” he said. “I can spot the issues and drive people to the center and to common ground.”

“I make everyone come to a settlement conference - the litigants, the insurance adjusters and the attorneys. Then, I’ll talk to each side separately, and then mediate a resolution."

He said he also gets a good response to his Court in the Classroom program for area high schools.

Mr. Krieger, 54, of Delmont, has been an attorney for 23 years and a state lawmaker for nearly seven years. He has practiced corporate law in Pittsburgh and Greensburg, but disagrees that trial experience is the best indicator of a good judge.

“I know my way around a courtroom,” he said, noting he had trial cases in federal bankruptcy court and in commercial litigation.

Advertise with us

“But being a trial attorney is only one piece - attorneys want to win a case for their clients, but judges do something else,” he said. "I try to show people that I am fair and will act with wisdom and achieve justice.”

“People are concerned about what they see nationally, and the courts overstepping their bounds, making policy decisions for us when we are capable of making them ourselves, or having lawmakers enact laws.

“I will act with humility and restraint to enforce the law as written,” he said.

Mr. Smail, 49, has been serving in family court for a year, and before that had 17 years in civil and family law.

He said he’s been able to focus on his experience as a judge in the general election, but is limited in campaigning because he has a full daily schedule of adoptions, divorce and child custody cases.

Advertise with us

“You want to bring a case to resolution as quickly as possible when children are involved,” he said, adding the courts are moving more to shared custody of children. He said the children always tell him the truth if parents disagree on issues.

Mr. Smail said Donald Trump’s national campaign has excited people on the local level to ask candidates their positions on issues.

“He’s lit conservatives on fire,” he said of Mr. Trump, noting that Democrats in Westmoreland County are also conservative on social and fiscal issues and he is conservative.

Mr. Mears, 44, has 19 years experience as a civil court attorney and is solicitor for the newly-created Westmoreland County Land Bank, which purchased the former Monsour Medical Center in order to demolish it.

“Over the past 10 years, I’ve tried more civil cases than any other attorney in the county,” he said, adding that he learned about judicial temperament from his father, who is a retired Greensburg attorney.

Advertise with us

He said he’s knocked on approximately 12,000 doors, and he is focusing on areas in which he didn’t do as well in the primary and hasn’t been as well-known - in the northern end, southwest and west.

He said he was concerned after the primary that he was the only non-incumbent of the four judge candidates, but he finds that people appreciate that.

“People will ask me if I’ve ever held public office and when I say no, they say they’ll vote for me,” he said. “People seem to be disgusted with incumbents of both parties and want a change."

Debra Duncan, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.