Proposed legislation that would alter the borough’s pension ordinance sparked controversy among officials Monday at Carnegie council’s meeting.

Conflict arose after council members voted 6-0 to advertise an ordinance to amend the borough’s municipal pension plan, which is administered by the Pennsylvania Municipal Retirement System.

Councilman Rick D’Loss, who is finance chairman, said the ordinance, which affects nonuniform employees only, would increase pensions, remove caps and lower retirement ages, as well as save health care costs because no nonuniform employees hired after the first of this year would receive spousal health care benefits.

The health care benefits alone would save the borough $80,000, Mr. D’Loss said. Action from local officials is needed for the ordinance to be backed by the state, he said.

Advertise with us

But Mayor Jack Kobistek had reservations.

He said the change would require the borough to assume all liability from the changes, as well as make the first payment in 2017. Also, the current plan that was 96 percent funded would be reduced to 74 percent, resulting in a $912,137 deficit in 10 years.

“This, to me, is a significant investment. I’m a little disappointed that we didn't discuss this further,” the mayor said.

More specifically, he was bothered by the lowered retirement age from 62 to 60, the increased benefit accrual rate from 2 to 2.5 percent for each year of both past and future credited service, the lack of a cap on final salaries and whether the changes would result in a shortfall in the pension fund.

But Mr. D’Loss countered that “this will be one of the best pension plans in the state.” Officials are trading future health care costs, which are an unknown entity, for a figure that is known, he pointed out.

Advertise with us

However, the mayor was adamant that more group discussion should have occurred.

“We get better results [with discussion],” he said.

In an email the next day, he wrote, “I believe this process could have been more transparent. There was very little information (or discussion) about the financial implications of the contracts along the way. I have concerns about how these obligations will affect our future budgets.”

“A lot of workers will retire with a pension higher than their original salaries were. One employee will get $83,000 in retirement money,” the mayor said.

The mayor also expressed displeasure that the pension numbers were not available earlier.

Advertise with us

“We have no clue what the total savings will be,” he said after the council meeting.

Carnegie has three unions: public works with 10 employees, administration with three workers and the 13-member police department.

Carole Gilbert Brown, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.