After years of feuding capped by a bitter primary election battle, county Executive Rich Fitzgerald and county Controller Chelsa Wagner met for lunch Thursday in what both described as an effort to forge a more productive approach to the issues of county government.

Events will determine whether the meal was merely symbolic or a genuine turning point in their stormy relationship, but in a joint statement both Democrats offered optimistic assessments of the prospects for their future. Perhaps wary of disturbing their newfound detente, neither responded to requests for interviews to elaborate on their conversation. They confined their remarks to the prepared statement emailed to reporters Friday afternoon.

“Nobody benefits when elected officials argue,”' said Mr. Fitzgerald, a figure who has often seemed to revel in arguments. “I’m glad that the Controller and I were able to clear the air and agree to put aside any differences.

“Working cooperatively, we are more likely to find efficiencies and savings that benefit Allegheny County taxpayers. At the end of the day, we agree that the County taxpayers are our boss and who we should be serving. By focusing on that, and our commonalities, Allegheny County residents benefit.”

Advertise with us

The statement came 10 days after a primary election in which Ms. Wagner triumphed in a battle for renomination over Mark Patrick Flaherty, a challenger supported politically and financially by Mr. Fitzgerald. The executive’s embrace of the Flaherty challenge followed four years in which Mr. Fitzgerald and Ms. Wagner clashed repeatedly. Their fractious relationship was exemplified by Mr. Fitzgerald’s decision to oust Ms. Wagner from a holiday party he hosted during a political gathering in New York City.

In another charged confrontation, Ms. Wagner released an audit last year accusing Mr. Fitzgerald of improperly using a county car for personal and political purposes. Mr. Fitzgerald denounced the audit as a political attack. But to defuse the issue, he returned the car and wrote the county a check for $42,700, representing the reimbursement for every mile recorded during his use of the vehicle.

Despite that history, Ms. Wagner’s statement echoed the conciliatory tone.

“I am encouraged that Rich and I engaged in an important discussion yesterday on general governance, and also touched on important policy topics for Allegheny County taxpayers, ranging from healthcare at the jail to regional economic development to the internal operations of County government,” she said. “I look forward to building on this conversation to forge a productive relationship that can result in the most effective, innovative and responsive government for our residents. I believe that we share that goal.”

Mr. Fitzgerald was unopposed for his own re-election, but beyond the Wagner victory, primary night brought him other reminders of his political limits. He had split with a former ally, the late county Councilwoman Barbara Daly Danko, on issues including the extent to which natural gas drilling should be permitted. In the wake of their estrangement, he championed the candidacy of her primary opponent, Caroline Mitchell.

Advertise with us

Ms. Danko died of cancer two weeks before the primary but her name remained on the ballot. Despite her death and Mr. Fitzgerald’s energetic support of Ms. Mitchell, the Danko ballot line won the most votes on May 19. It’s impossible to know how much of her winning total was a tribute to her memory, and how much it reflected a backlash against the executive who preceded her in the East End seat.

But, according to Sam Hens-Greco, the Democratic Party chairman of Squirrel Hill's 14th Ward, and one of the supporters of the posthumous vote for Ms. Danko, Mr. Fitzgerald told him in a recent conversation that he planned to stay out of the Democratic committee’s selection process for a successor nominee.

Whether that’s further evidence of a post-primary charm offensive by the executive is unclear. Neither he nor Ms. Wagner offered any more details of their lunch. Asked if crow had been on the menu, his aide, Amie Downs, said in an email, “They had Italian.”

Politics editor James P. O’Toole: jotoole@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1562.