Nine attorneys are running in the May 19 primary for three open judge seats in Westmoreland County Common Pleas Court.
All have cross-filed for nominations from both parties, so three will be selected on the Republican ballot and three on the Democratic ballot to face off in the general election in November.
County judges serve a 10-year term, with an annual salary of $176,000.
Here are the candidates:
Tom Anderson
Age: 44
Hometown: Mt. Pleasant Township
Party: Republican
Experience: 20 years courtroom experience; medical malpractice defense attorney for Pittsburgh law firm Thomson, Rhodes & Cowie
Mr. Anderson is running because he wants to make a difference for victims of domestic abuse.
His sister, Rebecca Stahl, a Derry Area teacher, was murdered three years ago by her husband, and Mr. Anderson’s family sat through the trial last year.
“I think I have a unique perspective, and most victims don’t have a voice,” he said. He’d like to see therapy dogs used in women’s shelters and courtrooms to help victims as they sit in the same room as their abusers.
“I see people sitting next to each other in trials and protection-from-abuse hearings, too, and I think that’s a bad idea. I think having a family member who experienced domestic abuse would give me a good perspective serving as judge,” he said.
“I think to be a good judge you first need to be a good trial lawyer and I am uniquely qualified. … I have had 25 cases that have gone to verdict — all over the region, from Fayette County to Erie. And many have been complex, two-week medical malpractice cases."
He has represented doctors and all the major hospitals in the region, he said.
■ ■ ■
Hope Aston
Age: 50
Hometown: Hempfield
Party: Republican
Experience: Prosecutor in family court for delinquent support cases; hearing officer in the county’s family court for the past five years; two years working for Laurel Legal Services as attorney for low-income victims of domestic abuse
Mrs. Aston has been an attorney for 17 years, working most of that time with families and children — and she wants to continue that work as a family court judge.
“I want to make sure we have the right judges with the right education and right legal and life experiences and the right temperament,” she said. “I have been preparing for this by deciding cases for the past five years."
She conducts hearings and makes recommendations to the four family court judges. She estimates she has held more than 2,500 hearings.
“Ninety-nine percent of my recommendations [to the judges] have been upheld. And in the majority of cases, the issues are resolved by the consent of the two parties. That means the issues don’t need to be litigated and that saves the taxpayers money,” she said.
“I love this job and working with families.If these families are in crisis, that affects the community."
She said, ”Our goal is always shared custody of children. But families are changing — we have grandparents raising children, great-grandparents raising children and fathers who are the custodial parent."
■ ■ ■
Christopher Huffman
Age: 47
Hometown: Rostraver
Party: Democrat
Experience: Assistant public defender and private attorney for 20 years; ran for judge in 2009; solicitor for South Huntingdon
Mr. Huffman is running because, he said, the community is under siege from heroin and violence in the schools.
“The drug problem is destroying the lives of our kids and families, and I’d like to try to make a difference with my experience,” he said.
“We need to identify at-risk people early on — those people stealing from their parents and grandparents and breaking into homes to pay for their habit,” he said.
Court officials and county commissioners have wanted to start a drug court, separate from the criminal court, to emphasize treatment over punishment, but county commissioners recently said a drug court appears to be too expensive, so they are looking for grants.
Mr. Huffman said said he would be interested in serving in juvenile court because he could help identify teens early who are involved with drugs and get them into outpatient treatment.
“Sometimes, the extra involvement from a judge can keep people on track,” he said. “I see people in my job every day who are addicted to heroin. They don’t want to be addicted, but they need help and the tools to turn their lives around.”
He said he would like to work with other judges to establish a fast-track docket for civil trials because they often take two to three years to come to trial, increasing the cost. He said a judge could ask the two sides in a case to agree to a “rocket docket,” which would bring the case to trial within six months.
■ ■ ■
Tim Krieger
Age: 53
Hometown: Delmont
Party: Republican
Experience: State representative for six years; practicing attorney for 25 years, currently in the Greensburg office of Strassburger McKenna Gutnick & Gefsky
Mr. Krieger campaigns when he is not in the state House in Harrisburg.
“Being in Harrisburg, and one of 203 members, we see the broad range of issues. It can be frustrating with those numbers, but it’s designed to be that way, slow and building a public consensus on legislation. As a judge, you have a more direct impact on a case or family."
He said most of his law practice, in small and large firms in Pittsburgh, has been in civil matters — banking and commercial law. His Greensburg practice primarily works in civil law as well.
“My judicial philosophy is one of restraint,” he said, adding a courtroom shouldn’t be the place for social experimentation. He said voters tell him they don’t want activist judges.
Mr. Krieger, who serves on the House Judiciary Committee, said he’d like to make civil jury trials more accessible, noting that the majority are settled before trial and the number of trials is declining.
“We need to expedite them and make them more efficient and make them less expensive," he said.
■ ■ ■
Scott Mears
Age: 44
Hometown: Unity
Party: Democrat
Experience: Greensburg civil law attorney with 19 years experience, currently with Mears, Smith, Houser & Boyle; solicitor for Westmoreland County Land Bank
Mr. Mears said he has always wanted to be a judge and to do what is fair under to the law. Being a judge, he said, gives a person the freedom to make the right decision and not be beholden to a client.
He said he’d be happy to serve in any of the court divisions — civil, family or criminal.
“Family law may be the most important of the three,” he said, adding a judge there could make a difference in children’s lives.
He said practicing law with his father has given him an appreciation for a calm, judicial temperament.
The Westmoreland County Land Bank, for which he is solicitor, buys abandoned or neglected property in an effort to put it back on the tax rolls.
“When I tell people in the Route 30 corridor that we purchased the old Monsour Hospital, they really appreciate that,” he said.
■ ■ ■
David Regoli
Age: 49
Hometown: Lower Burrell
Party: Democrat
Experience: Attorney for 23 years in criminal and civil practice, three years in public defender’s office; appointed judge by Gov. Tom Corbett in July, serving in civil court; Lower Burrell council member for 16 years
Judge Regoli has served in civil court for eight months since his appointment.
“A large part of what a civil court judge does is in pre-trial motions, since a lot of cases are settled before they come to trial,” he said, "and I had a lot of experience in that in recent years in my private practice.“
“I like the academic challenge of each case — you can be talking about a slip and fall, or product liability, or an asbestos case. Every day it’s different, and my law clerk and I take the attorneys’ briefs and then do the research into the case law."
“People ask me whether I’m a Democrat or Republican, but that has no bearing in my courtroom. I want people to know that I won’t let politics or ideology enter into my courtroom. I want them to know I will be fair and impartial and go by the evidence. We follow the law, we don’t make laws."
Judge Regoli began a Court in the Classroom program late last year. He presides as attorneys argue two or three civil court cases once a month at a local high school to help educate students about the legal system.
He began a veterans court when he was appointed to the bench. It allows a veteran who may have had a traumatic injury to get treatment and supervision from the federal government and then apply to have charges dismissed if the veteran successfully completes the treatment.
■ ■ ■
Jim Silvis
Age: 39
Hometown: Unity
Party: Republican
Experience: Greensburg attorney for 13 years with O’Connell & Silvis; assistant county solicitor and former public defender; on board of directors for Westmoreland County Historical Society, Laurel Legal Services, and Greensburg-Hempfield Library
Mr. Silvis learned what it meant to be an attorney from his father.
“Growing up in the area, I’ve always tried to be involved in the community in any way I can,” he said. "I was raised in a legal family — my father still practices law — so we’d sit around the dinner table and talk about his cases and what was fair.
“I think I have the temperament to be a good judge — a calm demeanor, where you don’t let emotions get in the way of thinking clearly. You have to keep your head about you and be reasonable and fair to all parties.”
He said voters “want a fair shake, and to be able to tell a judge what is important to them and know a judge has not made his mind up.”
“Judges don’t make laws, so voters want someone they can trust, who will follow the law and treat people fairly,” he said.
Although he currently handles predominantly civil cases, he had experience with criminal cases when he was in the county public defender’s office.
“I like civil cases, they are often complex, where you need a broad knowledge, and I love learning and expanding my knowledge."
■ ■ ■
Harry Smail
Age: 49
Hometown: Greensburg
Party: Republican
Experience: Private civil and family law attorney for 17 years; appointed judge by Gov. Tom Corbett in July, serving in family court
Judge Smail has been serving in family court for the past eight months since his appointment.
“Over 17 years in litigation and seven years in the parole office have properly trained me for the job,” he said.
The majority of cases he sees involve child custody and support, divorce and the distribution of property.
“You want to bring a case to resolution as quickly as possible. Young children may be stuck in limbo, or you want to see that both parents have an equal share to see their children,” he said.
“I like to say I see a lot of good people on their worst day,” he said. “There may be something negative going on, but I try to diffuse that by being very direct and using common language to get to the core of the problem. And if the parents can’t work something out because of hostility, I interview the children, and they always tell me the truth.”
He said one parent usually has primary custody of a child still but the courts are moving more to equal or shared custody of children.
“We have many more fathers who want to be participants now, and we have more mothers who have professional careers,” he said.
■ ■ ■
Leslie Uncapher Zellers
Age: 49
Hometown: Allegheny Township
Party: Republican
Experience: Assistant district attorney for six years; law clerk for Judge Rita Hathaway for eight years; currently in private practice in Vandergrift in all areas of law
Mrs. Zellers wanted to run for judge two years ago when she still was a law clerk but, as a judicial employee, could not run for political office. She resigned that position a few months ago to run this campaign.
Her experience in the district attorney’s office and as an attorney representing children in foster care or in custody cases gave her one perspective on the law, she said, but working as a law clerk for a judge every day gave her an appreciation for reasoned and well-rounded decisions that require taking both sides into consideration.
“I wish the public knew how much thought and effort goes into a judge making these decisions,” she said. “They are not off-the-cuff decisions. You need to consider all the evidence and the credibility of the people involved. And in every single case, there is extensive research into the case law and the precedents set by higher courts.”
She said she has enjoyed working in family court.
She has been appointed by the courts to represent parents in child cases and to represent children in custody hearings or those removed from their homes and living in foster care. She also has been appointed to represent juveniles.
Debra Duncan, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.