South Fayette commissioners have voted to censure member Deron Gabriel for approaching the solicitor about municipal matters without the knowledge of the majority of the board.
The censure motion March 18 by commissioner Jessica Cardillo-Wagenhoffer was approved by a 4-0 vote. Mr. Gabriel was absent.
Ms. Cardillo-Wagenhoffer said Mr. Gabriel sought an opinon regarding felony insurance fraud charges filed against her by the State Attorney General’s office in September, 2014, and asked the solicitors’ office for a legal opinion about plans for the Watson Institute.
“As far as I know, he asked the solicitor for an opinion,” Ms. Cardillo-Wagenhoffer said, referring to a September 2014 published report about her insurance fraud charges. In it, Mr. Gabriel stated his intentions to seek the solicitor’s advice regarding her need to resign from office.
“It's not about me, or my personal life. It's about the actions that have been taken without consent or approval of the board,” she said of her censure motion, citing a cost to tax payers as a main concern.
Mr. Gabriel said as a member of the board’s legal committee, he believes it is his obligation to seek advice from the solicitor.
“Residents have come to me, and other commissioners, asking whether or not she [Ms. Cardillo-Wagenhoffer] should have resigned,” he said. “I don’t think it was a secret to anyone that we wanted to know what the law was.”
He also cited a section of the First Class Township Code, which in part states that a solicitor shall furnish the Board with his opinion in writing when a question of the law is submitted by any member of the board in their official capacities.
Mr. Gabriel said he was acting in good faith for residents.
Board President, Joseph Horowitz, said he sought the solicitor’s opinion in this matter as well.
Mr. Gabriel substantiated that he also sought the opinion of the solicitor regarding the property where the Watson Institute will be constructing a new building.
“The township put a lot of money and upkeep into the soccer fields on the property, as well as paid the real estate taxes,” he said. “It was a legal question in the sense of whether or not we could purchase the property. It was driven by the financial information.”
Commissioner Lisa Ann Malosh said she voted for the censure motion because “I believe in adhering to professional standards and procedures.” She felt it was not appropriate for one member to act on behalf of the majority without having had the appropriate discussions.
She said she would have preferred Mr. Gabriel to be present at the meeting, but “I do not think his presence would have changed the outcome.”
Mr. Gabriel said he did not think it was appropriate for the censure vote to take place in his absence.
Commissioner Raymond Pitetti said the issues go beyond Mr. Gabriel’s requests for opinions from the solicitor.
“While several attempts were made to discuss his actions and to ask him to comply with the established rules and etiquette, he chose to continue to act on his own,” Mr. Pitetti said.
Commissioner Joseph Horowitz said Mr. Gabriel's actions and correspondences regarding proposed zoning corrections were worthy of being censured. John and Stacy Kosky have requested the township examine and correct maps that they believe zone portions of their property erroneously.
“Commissioner Gabriel demanded that our solicitor provide him personally, as he asserted was his right and obligation, with a legal opinion,” Mr. Horowitz said.
The request was part of a flurry of emails that included township manager, Ryan Eggleston, and solicitors as recipients.
“The tone and content of these emails put me, and everyone else who received them, in a very difficult position,” said Mr Horowitz. “Commissioner Gabriel should have discussed his concerns with the entire board in a public setting.”
Amy Philips-Haller, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.