In a stuffy courtroom in the City-County Building Wednesday, a judge ruled that two Allegheny County Council candidates should not be allowed to run in the May primary election, effectively leaving candidates for those seats now uncontested.
Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Joseph M. James struck from the May 19 primary ballot Eric S. Smith, who was running in District 10, and Richard Bradford, who was challenging incumbent John DeFazio for an at-large seat, because of separate issues concerning signatures on their election petitions. Bill Robinson, the current District 10 county council member and longtime elected official, withdrew from the race before his petition challenge.
Better Jobs Better Future, a political action committee supporting another District 10 candidate, DeWitt Walton, and other county office seekers, financed the challenges. Committee chairman Mike Mikus, who is also spokesman for county controller candidate Mark Patrick Flaherty, said he did not know the cost ofthe efforts.
The PAC challenged all but 15 of the signatures in Mr. Robinson’s election petitions — which included Jerome Bettis, “Russel Crowe” and Naomi Watts — asserting that no one with those names, or many others on the petitions, could be found in county voter records.
A notary public signed Mr. Robinson’s withdrawal notice two days later, and he was formally removed from the ballot Tuesday. In a text message to a reporter sent from a phone number listed for him, Mr. Robinson wrote Wednesday, “I’m not a candidate.” He did not answer specific questions.
Mark Wolosik, county elections division manager, said Mr. Robinson could run as a write-in candidate.
Judge James ruled that Mr. Smith should be removed from the ballot because a woman who circulated his petitions testified that she filled in dates for some elderly signatories, but didn’t know how many or which ones.
Handwriting expert Michelle Dresbold testified that some date and address information appeared to be written by the same hand.
Mr. Smith largely declined comment after the hearing, only saying he was “shocked.”
Those decisions mean Mr. Walton will be unopposed for the Democratic nomination in District 10, which includes east neighborhoods in Pittsburgh and adjoining suburbs.
In the at-large race, Mr. Bradford, a family advocate specialist for the county department of human services who is also a Wilkinsburg school board director, met with an attorney for the challenger before his hearing, and the two agreed that 58 signatures were invalid.
He said the addresses for those signatories on his filings didn’t match where those people were registered to vote.
“Rules are rules. I understand,” Mr. Bradford said.
He said later that he plans to run as a write-in candidate.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.