Remaining silent is an absolute right of every criminal defendant based on the 1966 U.S. Supreme Court case, Miranda v. Arizona. Based on that same case law, a prosecutor may not use that silence as a commentary on the defendant’s guilt at trial.
But the courts have long been unsettled on whether a prosecutor may comment on a defendant’s pre-arrest silence.
In Pennsylvania, that question was decided in November when the state Supreme Court found that comments by an Allegheny County prosecutor at closing about the defendant’s refusal to cooperate in the investigation were a violation of the Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination.
“While the prosecutor’s argument is not evidence, the prosecutor used the evidence referencing defendant’s silence to imply his guilt, in essence making him ‘a witness against himself by unspoken assumed answers,’ ” the court wrote.
The panel, split by 3-2, vacated the third-degree murder conviction of Michael Molina and remanded the case for retrial.
Jury selection begins today before Judge David R. Cashman of Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.
Molina, 42, an ex-convict, is accused of killing Melissa Snodgrass in September 2003.
Snodgrass, who reportedly owed Molina money, was reported missing is early September 2003, and her mummified body was discovered in the basement of a Spring Garden home in March 2004.
A witness in the case told investigators that she saw Snodgrass, 21, at that home and that Molina struck the young woman on the head with a handgun. The witness fled after that.
During the missing person’s investigation, Molina called police to say he had heard he was a suspect in the case. He told the detective he hadn’t seen Snodgrass for more than a year but then immediately contradicted himself to say it had been about three months.
When the detective asked Molina if he would go to the police station to talk to investigators in their office, he refused.
After Snodgrass’ body was found, Molina was arrested and went to trial. He did not testify.
During closing arguments, the chief trial deputy district attorney, Daniel Fitzsimmons, referenced Molina’s lack of cooperation.
“He refuses to cooperate with the missing persons detectives,” the prosecutor said. “And why?”
Then-defense attorney Patrick Thomassey objected saying the comments were improper. Mr. Fitzsimmons replied, “Your honor, pre-arrest silence is not improper comment at all.”
At sidebar, Mr. Thomassey said, “If somebody wants to assert their right not to cooperate and talk to the police, that cannot be commented upon.”
Mr. Fitzsimmons responded “There’s a sharp line drawn between pre-arrest silence and post-arrest silence.”
Judge Cashman overruled the defense, and Mr. Fitzsimmons continued about Molina’s silence, “Factor that in when you’re making an important decision in this case as well.”
The jury convicted Molina of third-degree murder, and he was sentenced to 20 to 40 years in prison.
He appealed his conviction, arguing that Mr. Fitzsimmons’ comments to the jury violated his right against self-incrimination.
The state Superior Court agreed with the defense, and in November, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court affirmed.
According to the 42-page opinion, the U.S. Supreme Court has said that the prosecution may comment on pre-arrest silence if it is done to impeach a defendant who testifies at trial. But it has not addressed the question when the defendant does not take the stand.
In the Molina appeal, the prosecution argued that the right against self-incrimination does not ‘‘extend backward’’ to cover the pre-arrest time frame.
But the defense countered that what Miranda did was make sure defendants were aware of their rights, not limit them to only after arrest.
‘‘Moreover, defendant contends that to provide protection of the right against self-incrimination only upon arrest places the right inappropriately in the hands of the police,” the court explained.
“According to the defendant, the police will interview a suspect prior to arrest in order to obtain either a statement or silence, knowing that the individual’s pre-arrest silence can be used as evidence of guilt at trial, even though the same silence could not be used if it occurred the moment after arrest.”
The state Supreme Court found that Molina did invoke his right to silence in the phone call with the detective.
‘‘We determine that defendant’s actions in affirmatively and definitively refusing to come to the police station and ending the phone call were sufficient to invoke his right against self-incrimination,’’ the court ruled.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.