Allegheny County’s property reassessment in 2013 left many homeowners wondering why they ended up having to pay more in taxes than their neighbors.
In an attempt to address wide disparities in values among seemingly similar properties, Mt. Lebanon embarked on a program to appeal assessments that, using certain criteria, indicated the amounts were too low.
For 2013 and 2014, the municipality focused on properties that were purchased from 2006 through 2013, which drew criticism from the affected homeowners that not all property sales were being treated equally.
This year, Mt. Lebanon has changed the criteria in an attempt to ascertain “the most egregiously underassessed properties” regardless of the sale year, according to a fact sheet about the appeal program issued by the municipality.
The fact sheet is on the municipal website, and copies were made available during a recent meeting of Mt. Lebanon commissioners.
“Our long-term strategy was to find a way to find the most underassessed properties in the municipality, and in 2015, our strategy resulted in 26 properties that will be tax appealed,” John Bendel, commission president, said at the March 10 meeting.
“In the process that we used this year, of the 26, 80 percent of those will be properties that were purchased between 1989 and 2005. Only five of the properties would have been recent sales,” he said, referring to purchases made in 2014.
The greatest discrepancy in assessment versus comparable value in a single property was $356,600, and the lowest was $112,133, according to the fact sheet.
In addition to drawing criticism from the affected homeowners, the appeal program is a subject of concern for an organization that advocates for property rights.
The Realtors Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh is calling for Mt. Lebanon to establish appeal criteria that will not change from year to year.
“We’d like to see a formula that everyone can understand before they buy their homes,” said Preston Moore of Howard Hanna Real Estate Services, 2015 president of the Realtors Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh. “We don’t want any surprises.”
The organization opposes efforts by taxing bodies to target specific properties.
“RAMP does not agree with the process of ‘spot’ assessment,” said association treasurer Charlene Haislip of Re/Max Realty Brokers. “We don’t think that’s fair. It’s a Band-Aid to the problem we have in the whole state, the mishmash of the way property assessment is addressed.”
Pennsylvania is one of nine states in which the timing and method of reassessment is made by each county, according to a 2010 study conducted for the Center for Rural Pennsylvania, a legislative agency of the General Assembly.
At the time of the study, many counties had not conducted a reassessment for decades. Washington County, for example, had its last reassessment in 1981, and five others had gone more than 30 years without a reassessment, including Blair County’s most recent in 1958.
Allegheny County was under court order to conduct its 2013 reassessment. In its wake, the county’s Board of Property Assessment, Appeals and Review has been deluged with appeals from property owners and various taxing bodies, including municipalities.
“We’re not picking on Mt. Lebanon, as if nobody else does it,” Ms. Haislip said. “What we can do is advocate to tell each individual municipality, if you’re going to do this, you need to publish your criteria beforehand, widely, and make it unchanging.”
Mt. Lebanon does note in its appeal program fact sheet: “The new criteria also will be able to be used in future years.”
Harry Funk, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.