A school board race in the city’s South Hills may be reshaped by how a Common Pleas Court judge decides what makes a house a home.
Three candidates are seeking to replace outgoing school board member Sherry Hazuda in District 6 : Samuel Hurst, Moira Kaleida and Tracy Link. But Ms. Kaleida, who has been endorsed by Democratic Party elders and the teacher’s union, is seeking to remove Ms. Link from the ballot, by challenging her nominating petitions.
Ms. Link is “claiming to live in a boarded-up house,” said Ms. Kaleida.
Ms. Link’s nomination papers list her address as being on Merrimac Street, in Mount Washington. But Ms. Kaleida’s petition alleges that Ms. Link actually resides in the West End, and that she “is not eligible for the [district 6 seat], as she resides outside of the electoral district.” That would mean that a sworn affidavit Ms. Link submitted with her papers was false, the filing argues. Candidates who file false affidavits can be removed from the ballot.
Ms. Link is a registered voter at the Merrimac Street address. County records also show the building, a two-family home, receives a homestead exemption, which confers a tax discount on primary residences.
Most of the building’s windows are boarded up, and no one answered at the address when a Post-Gazette reporter visited this morning. A neighbor who answered a nearby door said she “can’t really say” if anyone lived in the home.
Ms. Link declined to comment directly on the petition, because she said she was still seeking legal counsel. However, she added that the Mount Washington property “has been my mailing address for 15 years. We have taken measures to fix it as we can afford to. It’s a family home, and has been for lots of years.”
“This is my first campaign, and I’m not sure what I’m doing wrong,” she added. “I feel that I’m in the race for the right reasons, having been involved with schools for 17 years.”
Removing a candidate based on residency concerns “is among the more difficult challenges,” said Adam Bonin, a Philadelphia lawyer with expertise in election law. “Residency is a question both of physical location and intent. It’s not just where you spend most of your nights. You have to look at things like where you keep your memorabilia, where your kids go to school, where you are registered to vote.”
Chuck Pascal, the attorney who filed the petition to remove Ms. Link from the ballot, said that while voter registration and homestead exemption “are pieces of the puzzle” for determining residency, “there are other pieces as well.” He declined to discuss what those would be: “I don’t want to litigate my case in the press.”
The challenge is slated to be heard by Common Pleas Court Judge Joseph James on March 26.
Ms. Kaleida said she wasn’t trying to deny voters a choice, noting that another Mr. Hurst is still in the running. “You are representing people in the district,” she said, “and I don’t know how can represent people when you can’t see them.
“Her heart is the right place,” Ms. Kaleida said of Ms. Link. “Unfortunately, her address isn’t.”


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.