Former City Councilor Twanda Carlisle is poised to appear on the May primary ballot for City Council District 9 — the same seat she relinquished during a 2007 scandal involving the use of city money. Two other candidates in District 1, however, may not be so lucky.
The deadline for challenging a candidate’s appearance on the ballot was March 17, and no one filed such a challenge to Ms. Carlisle.
Ms. Carlisle did not respond to phone calls on Wednesday; council incumbent Ricky Burgess declined comment. Judith Ginyard, a challenger in the race, said she decided not to challenge Ms. Carlisle’s candidacy because “I have faith in the voters. She can’t take the seat, and it’ll be a total waste of taxpayer dollars to hold it.”
The campaign of another challenger, Stanton Heights businessman Andre Young, issued a statement decrying the “noise” in the race. Without addressing the decision not to challenge Ms. Carlisle’s candidacy, the statement called her “part of [an] old guard that has either been part of the problem or has sat on its hands …. Let’s focus on building up an area whose proximity to all the riches this city has to offer is so obviously untapped.”
The state constitution bars anyone from holding office if they’ve been “convicted of embezzlement of public moneys, bribery, perjury or other infamous crime.” Ms. Carlisle pleaded “no contest” to charges that she moved $43,160 of city money into personal and campaign accounts. Her nomination could have been challenged on that basis, but filing such a challenge can carry financial and political costs. At any rate, as the Post-Gazette first reported in February, even if Ms. Carlisle were to be elected, she could be removed from office by prosecutors under what is known as a “quo warranto” process.
For now, however, the focus will be on City Council District 1, where incumbent Darlene Harris faces four rivals: Mark Brentley Sr., David Schuilenburg, Bobby Wilson and Randy Zotter.
Mr. Brentley faces a two-part challenge, filed by attorney Carter Hoel on behalf of a district resident. One part of the petition alleges errors in 94 of the 191 signatures Mr. Brentley gathered. If those challenges were successful, it would leave Mr. Brentley with 97 valid signatures — three less than the 100 he needs.
But the challenge cites another potentially fatal flaw.
Under the state’s Public Official and Employee Ethics Act, candidates must file a Statement of Financial Interest that details income sources and any debts they carry. One copy must be attached to the petitions filed with the county’s elections office, but another must be filed with “the political subdivision wherein the candidate is seeking office.” In Pittsburgh, that means the statement must be filed with the City Clerk’s office. While Mr. Brentley included a statement with his election petitions, the complaint alleges, he did not furnish the city with a copy.
City Clerk Mary Beth Doheny confirmed that Mr. Brentley had not filed an ethics statement with her office by the March 10 deadline.
Mr. Brentley said Wednesday he couldn’t comment on the legal challenge, which he said he hadn’t seen. “I know absolutely nothing about this,” he said. “I am still calling around trying to get information.”
He would not be the first candidate to be tripped up by the requirement. Last year, a would-be Republican challenger to then-Gov. Tom Corbett was removed for a similar oversight.
The courts “don’t care if you got bad information” about filing requirements, said Adam Bonin, a Philadelphia attorney with expertise in election law. “There are no exceptions to this. It’s a fatal defect, end of story.”
Mr. Zotter, meanwhile, faces a challenge filed by attorney Chuck Pascal on behalf of two residents. Mr. Pascal’s suit alleges that Mr. Zotter’s nomination should be disallowed, because the same person wrote in the word “Pittsburgh” where the forms require signers to indicate what municipality they live in. Relying on earlier court rulings, the filing contends that election law “prohibits a person other than [the signer] from completing any part of a line” on the petition.
Mr. Zotter scoffed at the challenge. “We fully expected our opponents were going to object,” he said, “and quite frankly it’s a bit silly.”
His camp points to a state law that says that when an office being sought “lies wholly within any city, borough or township … it shall not be necessary for any signer of a nomination petition to state therein the city, borough or township of his residence.” If writing “Pittsburgh” wasn’t necessary in the first place, his side will argue, it shouldn’t matter who wrote it.
Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Joseph James is scheduled to hear the city council challenges March 25.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.