In Pennsylvania, judicial candidates often spend vast sums so voters will recognize their names on a ballot. But in the race for a seat on the state’s Superior Court, one Democrat may set himself apart with the opposite approach: spending as little money as possible.

“I have instructed my campaign committee to neither solicit nor accept a single penny in campaign contributions,” said Allegheny County Common Pleas Court Judge Robert J. Colville at a Tuesday morning news conference. He said he would spend his own money — “perhaps a few thousand dollars” — instead.

“Money, especially big money, has become a corrosive influence” in politics, he said. And though he didn’t fault other candidates for accepting contributions, “Our judiciary, perhaps above all other public institutions, should stand free from worrisome or improper influence.”

Pennsylvanians for Modern Courts, a nonpartisan court-reform organization, welcomed the news. Judge Colville’s move “points out some of the potential problems of judicial candidates raising money,” said Executive Director Lynn A. Marks. “If somebody perceives that a judge is going to be partial to a large contributor, they aren’t going to feel they got a fair shake.”

Advertise with us

Judge Colville previously garnered more than $180,000 for an unsuccessful 2009 Superior Court run. He said such contributions have not affected his rulings: Judges are barred from personally soliciting funds, and “I honestly did not know who made any donations to my campaign.”

But under judicial rules issued last year, judges are to recuse themselves if lawyers or parties in a case before them have made campaign contributions “in an amount that would raise a reasonable concern” about a judge’s impartiality. Judge Colville said that prompted him to pay more attention to contributions, inspiring his decision not to seek them at all.

Others running for Superior Court will not follow Judge Colville’s lead.

“In judicial races, voters often lack information about the candidates and even the offices they are seeking, so it’s incumbent on the candidates to educate them,” said Marty Marks, spokesman for Democratic Philadelphia Judge Alice Beck Dubow, who is competing against Judge Colville for the party nomination.  “Getting that message out requires resources, and that requires fundraising.”

Northampton County Common Pleas Judge Emil Giordano, the race’s lone Republican, said he lacked the big-city base of Judge Colville and Judge Dubow. “I don’t have any great wealth myself” with which to build name recognition, he added.

“To run a campaign statewide, I’m going to have to solicit funds,” he said.