After receiving only one development proposal for the Star City property, South Fayette officials will accept another round of submissions, which includes for the first time an option for applicants to purchase the land.

“We generated a lot of interest,” said township Manager Ryan Eggleston. “It’s encouraging.”

Roofing contractor Burns and Scalo submitted the only proposal for the approximate 8.5 acre site on Route 50 at the Interstate 79 junction. Township officials are hoping Burns and Scalo reapplies.

Commissioner Raymond Pitetti said the township should look at all options.

Advertise with us

“There were a number of businesses that were interested in the site, but only if they could buy it outright,” he said.

In 2009, the township paid $5 million for the property, which covered nearly 12 acres and housed a multiple-screen movie complex.

Commissioner Jessica Cardillo Wagenhoffer said other financial obligations were placed into a 25-year bond, resulting in approximately $8 million of financing. Of the original 12 acres, 2.7 acres have been sold to Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh of UPMC and 0.73 acres were parceled to Washington Financial Bank.

The original request for proposal was approved in August by commissioners with a 4-1 vote, with Ms. Cardillo Wagenhoffer opposing the lease-only option.

“I had expressed a desire for the property to be offered for sale then,” she said. “However, the RFP did not include that option, even after an amendment was proposed. While I am not pleased with the delay, I am hopeful that the new RFP changes will be attractive to developers.”

Advertise with us

The site, zoned C-2 commercial, is across Route 50 from the Newbury residential and retail development. Potential uses for the property would be retail, office space and hotels.

The developer will be required to demolish the Star City building, pay township and school taxes and provide 45,000 square feet for township facilities.

Ms. Cardillo Wagenhoffer admitted disappointment with the response thus far, noting the taxpayers burden needs removed.

“With all of the growth and improvement happening around this site, I was hoping to receive more bids on the RFP,” she said.

Mr. Pitetti said he was encouraged at the number of companies that approached the township.

Advertise with us

As for which is better, sale or lease, Mr. Pitetti said, “The proposals and the finances would dictate which is the best option.”

“If we could generate enough money from the sale of the property to offset the cost that the township has incurred — as well as generate additional revenue — I would be in favor of a sale.”

The new RFP is being drafted and will be posted on the township website.