Aspiring candidates, take note: If you’re seeking the Allegheny County Democratic Committee’s endorsement before the May 19 primary, the price of failure has increased substantially.

That’s because of a new fee structure which, depending on whom you ask, is either a reform to strengthen the party, or what Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner calls “the most anti-democratic thing I’ve ever seen.”

Endorsements are made by Democratic committee members before the primary. Endorsed Democrats gain bragging rights, and their names appear on slate cards distributed at polling places. But seeking the endorsement is optional, and the party elders’ blessing doesn’t come free.

Prior to this year, candidates seeking the endorsement paid filing fees with rates that varied depending on the office sought. During Ms. Wagner’s 2011 controller race, for example, she paid $3,000 to be considered. Once endorsed, candidates paid a second fee to help print and distribute slate cards: For Ms. Wagner, that was $4,000.

Advertise with us

The electoral math is changing this year, as those fees are being combined into one up-front charge, due Feb. 13. Ms. Wagner will pay $8,000, as will anyone challenging her for the endorsement. City Council hopefuls must come up with $3,500; candidates for Common Pleas Court will pay $7,000.

Although every candidate seeking the endorsement must pay the fee, candidates who don’t get endorsed can receive a 30 percent refund — if they drop out of the race.

Nancy Patton Mills, who chairs the Allegheny County Democratic Committee, said the cost of holding party events, as well as printing and mailing slate cards, increases every year. And the fee has been restructured, she said, “because the committee wants the endorsement to have some meaning.”

In the past, some local Democrats sought the committee endorsement and, after failing to get it, ran in the primary anyway. This year, such tactics will carry a price: Unendorsed candidates who stay in the race will lose the entire fee, some of which could help pay for slate cards that advertise an opponent.

“After many years of people grousing about it, we’ve found a way to encourage people to respect the endorsement,” said longtime Democratic attorney Chuck Pascal.

Advertise with us

“There are times it’s appropriate to run against endorsed candidates,” said Mr. Pascal, who has helped elect unendorsed candidates himself. “But overall, you want a strong party organization.” And giving the committee’s endorsements some teeth, he predicted, would encourage more involvement in the committee.

Still, the new approach has drawn criticism since notice of it went out this week. “The perception is that it’s a barrier to entry,” said Jim Burn, who formerly chaired the Allegheny County committee and currently chairs the party’s statewide apparatus.

Seeking the endorsement has become more of a gamble this year, even for candidates who drop out after failing to secure it.

In 2011, for example, a Pittsburgh City Council candidate who bowed out after losing the endorsement would have lost the $1,250 filing fee, but not been dunned for slate cards at all. This year, such a candidate would still be $2,450 in the hole, even after collecting the refund. Similarly, in 2011, unendorsed Common Pleas Judge candidates could limit their losses to the $2,500 filing fee by dropping out; in 2015, they stand to lose $4,900.

Ms. Wagner, for one, called the new approach “outrageous. What the committee is saying is, ‘We’ll hold your money for no reason other than to make it harder on the candidates who aren’t anointed.’”

Advertise with us

“We are not discouraging candidates, we are not anti-democratic,” countered Ms. Patton Mills. She noted that candidates can, and do, skip the endorsement process entirely, focusing solely on reaching voters instead. “You can run as an independent Democrat. Or as a Republican.”

That may be a route for the budget-conscious: While the Republican Committee of Allegheny County rarely makes endorsements, vice-chair David Majernik said, it doesn’t charge for them. But “this is a Democratic town,” said Ms. Patton Mills, who contended that an endorsement is often the best investment a candidate can make. “If you get a judicial endorsement, you will probably be a judge.”

In any case, Democratic political consultant Matt Merriman-Preston said, Pittsburgh city council races can cost $75,000. Given that, “If you’re a serious candidate, [the $3,500 fee] isn’t a terrible amount.”

The new policy “could cut both ways,” said lawyer Marc Daffner, who unsuccessfully sought the party endorsement in four separate runs for a Common Pleas judgeship.

The refund “might be an incentive to bend to the will of the party and drop out” after losing an endorsement, Mr. Daffner said. Then again, “You could get candidates who say, ‘[Forget] this. I’m not going to seek the endorsement at all.’”

Advertise with us

“Even if candidates get a refund, it’s preventing them from using that money during the campaign,” added Mr. Dafner, who isn’t running this year. “You can buy a lot of yard signs with that money.”

Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533