Mayor Bill Peduto’s proposal to reorganize the city’s Bureau of Building Inspection into a new department came under a microscope during a 2½-hour city council hearing on the plan that saw the mayor’s chief of staff square off against the mayor’s chief nemesis on council.
Councilwoman Darlene Harris has blasted the proposal to remove the bureau from the Department of Public Safety and create a new Department of Permits, Licenses and Inspection, and she pulled no punches Monday.
“This is games with people’s lives,” said Mrs. Harris in one of several combative exchanges with Kevin Acklin, the mayor’s chief of staff.
Mr. Acklin said Mrs. Harris was “quite willing to play politics with tragedies” by suggesting the move could lead to a loss of life in Pittsburgh. Mrs. Harris has cited a report on Philadelphia’s Department of Licenses and Inspections that was prepared in the wake of a 2013 building collapse that killed six people and injured 13 others and invited two members of the commission that prepared the report to attend Monday’s meeting.
Peter F. Vaira, a lawyer who served as executive director of the commission, said the Philadelphia department was created about 50 years ago to serve as a one-stop shop for licenses and inspections.
“It was a disaster from the time it started and got worse as it went along,” said Mr. Vaira, a former U.S. attorney for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
Edward M. Dunham Jr., another lawyer who served on the commission, said the department took on too many responsibilities and was dragged down by a lack of staffing and funding as well as poor management.
“They just had too much to do,” he said.
However, both said they could not make any recommendation on Mr. Peduto’s plan, noting they would need an in-depth study of Pittsburgh’s longstanding issues with its Bureau of Building Inspection.
Mr. Acklin said “elevating” Pittsburgh’s bureau to a department would not compromise safety, adding that the proposal involves creating the job of a “critical structures manager” to keep tabs on crucial structures like bridges and serve as a liaison to the public safety department. The reorganization also involves “cross-training” inspectors to allow them to do more types of inspections.
Public Safety chief Stephen Bucar told council Monday that the department needs to be streamlined, but whether the focus on public safety remains will depend on “who is the watchdog.”
“To sit here and give you an opinion as to whether it should be a bureau or a department is not within the scope of my experience,” Mr. Bucar said.
Asked why the reorganization had to happen outside of the confines of the public safety department, Mr. Acklin said Mr. Peduto campaigned on fixing bureau inspection and wanted to make the department directly accountable to him.
Several other council members expressed concern about removing BBI from public safety, and it was tough to gauge from Monday’s meeting whether the mayor has the votes to pass the measure, though the only vocal opposition has come from Mrs. Harris. Mr. Acklin would not comment on the level of support on council, which will take up the legislation again Wednesday.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.